Week 11 2025: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 11 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded.

Celebrity guest picker Patrick Mahomes went 6-1 on his picks this week, which matches Desmond Howard, Nick Saban and Pat McAfee. Kirk Herbstreit was at 5-1 due to abstaining from picking the game he was calling.

This biggest winner by far this week was GamedayJen for going 8-1 on picks this week. There will be quite the celebration in the household this week I’m sure.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

NamePctWinLoss
Steve_Coughlin10040
Roman_Harper10040
Joel_Klatt10040
Josh_Pate10040
Jordan_Rodgers10030
Ross_Dellenger10010
Matt_Leinart10010
Urban_Meyer10010
Brady_Quinn10010
Jennifer88.8981
Desmond_Howard85.7161
Nick_Saban85.7161
Pat_McAfee85.7161
Celebrity_Guest85.7161
JD_Pickell85.7161
Kirk_Herbstreit83.3351
Rece_Davis83.3351
Greg_McElroy83.3351
David_Pollack83.3351
Chip_Patterson81.25133
Shehan_Jeyarajah80123
Dusty_Dvoracek8041
Bruce_Feldman8041
Paul_Finebaum7531
Pat_Forde7531
Stewart_Mandel7531
Ralph_Russo7531
Tim_Tebow7531
Tom_Fornelli72.22135
Richard_Johnson72.22135
Andy_Staples66.6721
Danny_Kanell6032
Pete_Thamel5033
Phil_Steele5011
Randy_Cross44.4445
Aaron_Taylor44.4445
Rick_Neuheisel37.535
Brian_Jones22.2227
Mark_Ingram001
Average73.7517763

Week 11 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Screenshot

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Mississippi State+9.5 vs Georgia
West Virginia-6.5 vs Colorado

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: UConn+8.5
Desmond Howard: BYU+11.5
Stanford Steve: Wake Forest+6.5
Pat McAfee: Arkansas St+4.5
Nick Saban: Stanford+7.5
Rece Davis: Hawaii+6.5

Celebrity guest Patrick Mahomes:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Virginia over Wake Forest
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

Kirk Herbstreit:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Wake Forest over Virginia
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Iowa over Oregon
Georgia over Mississippi State

Desmond Howard:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Virginia over Wake Forest
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

Pat McAfee:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Notre Dame-26.5 vs Navy
Alabama over LSU
Wake Forest over Virginia
Florida State over Clemson
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

Nick Saban:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Virginia over Wake Forest
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 53-18 (74.65%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Week 11 2025: CFB picks from Josh Pate’s Ramen Noodle Express!

Here are your week 11 picks from Josh Pate’s Ramen Noodle Express!

Sam Houston State+20.5 vs Oregon State
Alabama-9.5 vs LSU
Florida State+2.5 vs Clemson
Iowa vs Oregon Under 42.5
Connecticut+8.5 vs Duke
Kansas+5.5 vs Arizona
FIU+1.5 vs MTSU
Maryland+1.5 vs Rutgers
Bowling Green+2.5 vs Eastern Michigan
Penn State+14.5 vs Indiana
Mississippi State+9.5 vs Georgia