Week 11 2026: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 11 is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded. Let’s jump right in.

Winners this week include Rece Davis and Pete Thamel at 6-1 picking games on the College Gameday Podcast. David Hale, Greg McElroy and Andy Staples went 7-2 picking games. However, our biggest winners this week were Pat McAfee and GamedayJen at 8-1 picking games this week. Congratulations to both on a great winning week.

On College Gameday, Pat McAfee had the best week at 8-1 as previously mentioned. Celebrity guest picker Ian Johnson had an unfortunate week going 3-6 on Gameday. Kirk Herbstreit went 3-5 picking one less game. Desmond Howard went 6-3 and Nick Saban went 5-4.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

NamePctWinLoss
Danny_Kanell10020
Pat_Forde10010
Urban_Meyer10010
Pat_McAfee88.8981
Jennifer88.8981
Rece_Davis85.7161
Pete_Thamel85.7161
Stewart_Mandel8041
Brett_McMurphy8041
David_Hale77.7872
Greg_McElroy77.7872
Andy_Staples77.7872
Shehan_Jeyarajah75155
Chip_Patterson75155
Bruce_Feldman7531
Ralph_Russo7531
David_Pollack72.7383
Josh_Pate71.4352
Aaron_Taylor71.4352
Dan_Wetzel71.4352
Tom_Fornelli70146
Richard_Johnson66.67147
Desmond_Howard66.6763
Chris_Fallica66.6721
JD_Pickell6032
Brian_Kelly57.1443
Nick_Saban55.5654
Brian_Jones5044
Rick_Neuheisel5044
Chase_Daniel5022
Roman_Harper5022
Tim_Tebow5022
Steve_Coughlin5011
Andrea_Adelson44.4445
Joel_Klatt4023
Kirk_Herbstreit37.535
Celebrity_Guest33.3336
Paul_Finebaum2513
Phil_Steele2513
Jimbo_Fisher002
Mark_Ingram001
Matt_Leinart001
Eric_Mac_Lain002
Brady_Quinn001
Average65.02197106

Week 11 2026: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Stanford Steve’s board, Super Dog picks, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Southern Cal+9.5 vs Indiana
Oklahoma State-3.5 vs Texas Tech
Oklahoma-2.5 vs Ole Miss

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Duke+14 vs Miami FL
Desmond Howard: Arkansas+7.5 vs South Carolina
Stanford Steve: Southern Cal+8.5 vs Indiana
Pat McAfee: Texas+4.5 vs LSU
Nick Saban: Minnesota+9.5 vs Penn State
Rece Davis: San José State+12.5 vs Air Force

Celebrity guest Ian Johnson:

Oklahoma State over Texas Tech
Texas over LSU
Arizona over Utah
Kentucky over Florida
Boise State over Oregon State
Michigan over Oregon
Southern Cal over Indiana
Ferris State over Roosevelt
SMU over Wake Forest

Kirk Herbstreit:

Oklahoma State over Texas Tech
Arizona over Utah
Kentucky over Florida
Boise State over Oregon State
Oregon over Michigan
Southern Cal over Indiana
Ferris State over Roosevelt
SMU over Wake Forest

Desmond Howard:

Oklahoma State over Texas Tech
LSU over Texas
Utah over Arizona
Kentucky over Florida
Boise State over Oregon State
Oregon over Michigan
Indiana over Southern Cal
Ferris State over Roosevelt
Wake Forest over SMU

Pat McAfee:

Texas Tech over Oklahoma State
Texas over LSU
Utah over Arizona
Florida over Kentucky
Boise State over Oregon State
Oregon over Michigan
Indiana over Southern Cal
Ferris State over Roosevelt
SMU over Wake Forest

Nick Saban:

Oklahoma State over Texas Tech
LSU over Texas
Utah over Arizona
Kentucky over Florida
Boise State over Oregon State
Oregon over Michigan
Southern Cal over Indiana
Ferris State over Roosevelt
Wake Forest over SMU

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 84-31 (73.04%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Week 10 2026: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 10 of the college football season is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded.

Andrea Adelson was our top picker overall this week going 8-0 on her picks, so congratulations to Andrea on a great winning week.

On College Gameday, Nick Saban tied with celebrity guest picker Jason Sudeikis at 7-2 for the top performance of the week. Kirk Herbstreit went 5-3, Desmond Howard went 5-4, and Pat McAfee brought up the rear at 6-3.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

NamePctWinLoss
Andrea_Adelson10080
Phil_Steele10020
Eric_Mac_Lain10010
Bruce_Feldman8041
Pat_Forde8041
Nick_Saban77.7872
Celebrity_Guest77.7872
Richard_Johnson76.47134
David_Hale7562
Brett_McMurphy7562
Tom_Fornelli70.59125
Shehan_Jeyarajah68.75115
Chip_Patterson66.67126
Rick_Neuheisel66.6763
Aaron_Taylor66.6763
Ralph_Russo66.6742
Steve_Coughlin66.6721
Danny_Kanell66.6721
David_Pollack63.6474
Kirk_Herbstreit62.553
Stewart_Mandel57.1443
JD_Pickell57.1443
Dan_Wetzel57.1443
Desmond_Howard55.5654
Brian_Jones55.5654
Josh_Pate5066
Brian_Kelly5044
Andy_Staples5044
Joel_Klatt5033
Greg_McElroy5033
Paul_Finebaum5022
Tim_Tebow5022
Heather_Dinich5011
Rece_Davis42.8634
Pete_Thamel42.8634
Chase_Daniel4023
Roman_Harper4023
Pat_McAfee33.3336
Jennifer33.3336
Chris_Fallica001
Jimbo_Fisher001
Average61.64188117