2012-13 Yearly results & Champion!

It is a bittersweet day around here at the Gameday blog.  The results for the season are in, and that means that we crown a new champion as we put the season to bed.  I found it interesting that both last year’s bowl champion (Tony Reali) and last year’s season champion (Jesse Palmer) both were not in the competition.  Tony Reali had no picks this year, and Jesse Palmer only had ten picks (going 7-3 overall).  This year, Ryen Russillo was on top of the leaderboard going 18-5 (78.26%) but 23 picks is not enough to be a champion around here.  Therefore, I am proud to bring you this year’s grand champion: Tom Luginbill at 58-17 (77.33%).  We had a handful of experts going into bowl season who were within reach of the coveted 80% barrier for the season.  Big names including Tom Luginbill, Lou Holtz, Pat Forde, Mike Bellotti, Colin Cowherd and so on.  Pat Forde had been on a tear this year sitting at 75.84%, but tanked the bowl season going 18-17.  Lou Holtz was at 75% even, but only picked two bowl games and got them wrong.  Cowherd and Bellotti both had a shot, but average finishes weren’t enough to boost them over the top.  Tom Luginbill was at exactly 80% headed into bowl season, but a 6-4 finish dropped him a few points which was still good enough for the gold.  Below you will find the full slate of results for the year, with the minor experts listed below (those who only picked a few games).

Tom Luginbill: Gameday Champion
Tom Luginbill: Gameday Champion

Our rookie of the year has to be Dari Nowkhah coming in at 72.6% in his first season here.  He took on the hosting duties on the new ESPN show College Football Daily, which is the spiritual successor to the greatly missed “Palmer & Pollack”, and he did pretty well.  Mark Schlabach did nicely this year at 64.41%, which was good enough to bring him up from last place in the all-time rankings (now taken on by Mike Greenberg after a disastrous bowl season).  Celebrity guests on Gameday did pretty crappy, so let us shame them at 55.65%.  Brian Griese is our anti-rookie of the year at 57.45%.  Last but not least, I really do have to give props to Lou Holtz.  In years past he has picked Notre Dame to win virtually every game they play, and this year he went bananas at 72.58% right.  I would have loved to have seen how smug he would have been if ND won the championship, but oh well.  I’m sure he’ll be back next year to pick them every game.

Thanks for reading; its been a great season.  Check back next August when things get going again.  Who knows, maybe this offseason I’ll write some bonus material here too.

Ryen Russillo: 18-5, 78.26%
Tom Luginbill: 58-17, 77.33%
Matt Stinchcomb: 12-4, 75%
Pat Forde: 310-110, 73.81%
Ed Cunningham: 8-3, 72.73%
Dari Nowkhah: 106-40, 72.60%
Lou Holtz: 45-17, 72.58%
Mike Bellotti: 65-25, 72.22%
Lee Corso: 128-50, 71.91%
Colin Cowherd: 99-39, 71.74%
Woody Paige: 5-2, 71.43%
Trevor Matich: 70.65%
Christian Fauria: 84-36, 70%
Jesse Palmer: 7-3, 70%
Kirk Herbstreit: 125-54, 69.83%
Mel Kiper Jr.: 30-14, 68.18%
Charles Arbuckle: 41-20, 67.21%
Brad Edwards: 42-21, 66.67%
Kevin Carter: 10-5, 66.67%
Matt Millen: 4-2, 66.67%
Jason Sehorn: 49-25, 66.22%
Jennifer’s Picks: 144-74, 66.06%
Mark Schlabach: 38-19, 64.41%
Desmond Howard: 92-52, 63.89%
Robert Smith: 97-56, 63.40%
David Pollack: 69-40, 63.30%
Mike Golic: 24-14, 63.16%
Dan Hawkins: 15-9, 62.5%
Danny Kanell: 23-15, 60.53%
Todd McShay: 52-35, 59.77%
Mark May: 46-32, 58.97%
Brian Griese: 27-20, 57.45%
Celebrity Guests: 69-55, 55.65%
Tim Cowlishaw: 5-4, 55.56%
Ivan Maisel: 3-3, 50%
Skip Bayless: 5-7, 41.67%
Chris Fowler: 2-3, 40%
Mike Greenberg: 13-22, 37.14%
Andre Ware: 1-3, 25%

Scott Van Pelt: 5-0, 100%
JA Adande: 3-0, 100%
Bob Ryan: 3-0, 100%
Kevin Blackistone: 2-0, 100%
Samantha Steele: 1-0, 100%
Jackie MacMullan: 1-0, 100%
Michael Smith: 4-1, 80%
Brock Huard: 3-1, 75%
Bill Plaschke: 0-1, 0%

2012 Regular Season Standings

As we ramp up to bowl season this Saturday, I thought we would take a moment to review where everyone stands heading into bowl season.  This has been a very strong year at the top, with Tom Luginbill currently sitting on top of things at 80% right (I’m not counting SVP or Michael Smith with 4 picks).  Pat Forde has been on a tear this year, and Lou Holtz is looking good headed into bowl season thanks to Notre Dame running the table.  Most years, his Notre Dame undefeated predictions lead to his demise.  On the other end of the spectrum is rookie Brian Griese who is trying his hardest to tank this season, and Mark May who is the victim of Dr. Lou’s historic run.  I’ll be updating all week with bowl picks, so check back often because who knows when the picks might start rolling in!

Scott Van Pelt: 100% (4-0)
Michael Smith: 100% (4-0)
Tom Luginbill: 80.00% (52-13)
Matt Stinchcomb: 80.00% (12-3)
Ryen Russillo: 77.27% (17-5)
Pat Forde: 75.84% (292-93)
Lou Holtz: 75.00% (45-15)
Brock Huard: 75.00% (3-1)
Colin Cowherd: 74.76% (77-26)
Mike Bellotti: 73.75% (59-21)
Dari Nowkhah: 72.41% (105-40)
Lee Corso: 72.02% (121-47)
Trevor Matich: 70.65% (65-27)
Kirk Herbstreit: 70.18% (120-51)
Christian Fauria: 69.75% (83-36)
Mel Kiper Jr.: 67.44% (29-14)
Charles Arbuckle: 66.67% (40-20)
Mark Schlabach: 66.67% (16-8)
Jesse Palmer: 66.67% (4-2)
Woody Paige: 66.67% (4-2)
Jason Sehorn: 66.22% (49-25)
Brad Edwards: 66.13% (41-21)
Jennifer’s Picks: 65.03% (119-64)
David Pollack: 64.71% (66-36)
Desmond Howard: 62.69% (84-50)
Dan Hawkins: 62.50 (15-9)
Danny Kanell: 61.11% (22-14)
Robert Smith: 61.02% (72-46)
Matt Millen: 3-2 (60.00%)
Mark May: 57.89% (44-32)
Todd McShay: 57.69% (30-22)
Brian Griese: 57.45% (27-20)
Celebrity Guests: 55.65% (69-55)
Skip Bayless: 40.00% (4-6)
Chris Fowler: 40.00% (2-3)
Andre Ware: 25.00% (1-3)

Week 14 2012: Gameday review!

It is a bittersweet day here at Cole’s Gameday Blog.  This is the last Saturday of the regular season, which means the last edition of College Gameday for the year.  However, that also means bowl season is about to start, and we are sure to get at least one or two Gameday editions from big bowl games.  Also, we all know that bowl season is where legends are made in the rankings here at my blog.  Anyways, Gameday was broadcasting live from Atlanta, GA (AKA the Dirty Dirty) for the big SEC Championship game between Alabama and Georgia.  Our expert panel is currently sitting at 16 to 5 in favor of the Crimson Tide over the Bulldogs, so gamblers take note.

Chris Fowler opened the show up on a sunny morning in Atlanta, which is a big change from the last couple of weeks where they opened the show in darkness on the West coast. Fowler was driving the bus with Herbie, Desmond and Pollack along for the ride.  Samantha Steele quickly took over for Fowler, as he disappeared to go do whatever Chris Fowler does for 45 minutes before the main show on ESPN.  Samantha Steele was looking good this morning, and Jennifer noted that she redeemed herself with a great outfit this week after last week’s questionable decision on Ms. Steele’s part.

Samantha Steele: Week 14
Samantha Steele: Week 14

The first hour of the show was pretty dry on content.  They spent a lot of time breaking down football games (who would have thunk it?).  Desmond and David talked Heisman for a while, coming to an agreement that this award is not a lock for Johnny Manziel.  They both think this award is still up in the air between Manziel, Colin Klein and Manti T’eo.  David got into some really deep analysis and informed us that Colin Klein will need to BALL OUT to win the Heisman tonight.  We got a piece with Todd McShay back in the studio, where he was LOOKING AT THE TAPE!!!  This week’s subject was Georgia QB Aaron Murray.  It was basically a 90 second kick in the crotch for Murray, with all of the tape pointing out his weaknesses.  Desmond and David both made some picks to end the first hour.  David had leaned strongly towards Georgia earlier this week, but both guys picked Bama to win the SEC championship tonight.

As the main show opened up on ESPN, Samantha Steele was sent to the bus, and David Pollack was dispatched to go use the internet.  This really has been my favorite 20 seconds of Gameday each week this year, as we get to see awkward David Pollack dressing up or doing something weird all while tweeting.  This week he put the apron back on, and was pretending to be smoking some meat in the tailgate area.  I say pretending, because he was mostly just poking at it repeatedly with a utensil while tweeting on his phone.

David Pollack: Lover of meat, lover of internet
David Pollack: Lover of meat, lover of internet

Notre Dame coach Brian Kelly joined the show to talk about generic coach things.  He was booed loudly by both crowds on location, and was good-natured about the whole thing.  Speaking of Notre Dame, let me use this opportunity to shoehorn in a screenshot of Mark May dressed up as a leprechaun from last week’s College Football Final.  Mark May had offered to dress up like this if Notre Dame went undefeated this year, and the payoff was glorious.

Mark May: Dedicated Irish fan
Mark May: Dedicated Irish fan

Gene W. had a decent piece on Jarvis Jones, about how his brother was murdered several years ago, and how his life spiraled out of control afterwards.  He was taken under the wing of a family friend who legally adopted him, and she got him back on the right track.  It is this positive influence, and the inspiration of his brother which he credits for his success on the field.  We saw the return of Bald Man on Campus with Scott Van Pelt.  This week he was in College Station to meet up with Johnny Manziel and talk about how his life has changed since coming into the Heisman talk.  I would like to take this opportunity to editorialize once again if you don’t mind indulging me.  While I don’t have a problem with the nickname Johnny Football, I am firmly opposed to the use of the nickname “Johnny Heisman” for this young man, whether or not he should win the Heisman trophy.  This nickname bothers me quite a bit, because the award is named after John Heisman.  This nickname is the antithesis of clever when it is merely the same name as the legendary figure that the award is named after.

Other random notes from today include Desmond Howard repeatedly forcing in references to Tupac Shakur’s lyrics, and Lee Corso’s confusion as to who Tupac Shakur was.  Tom Rinaldi was not quite as in-your-face this week as recent weeks, but he did get a few segments in.  He had a sit-down interview with Nick Saban.  Either Tom Rinaldi didn’t have a beatnik poetry piece this week, or I missed it somewhere.  The main piece, which was really good, was Rinaldi’s piece about Coastal Carolina’s head coach Joe Moglia.  Coach Moglia was a defensive coordinator at Dartmouth back in 1983, but quit that job to support his four children by working on Wall Street.  He went on to become CEO of TD Ameritrade, and made over $100 million before leaving the company in 2008.  After this, he decided to return to his passion; coaching football.  He took an unpaid assistant position under Bo Pelini at Nebraska before coaching in the UFL.  Now he finds himself the head coach at Coastal Carolina, and they have made the FCS playoff second round for the first time in school history.  He credits this success to his experiences running things on Wall Street.  I enjoyed the feedback from his players about his generosity towards the team.  They would say something about needing new cleats, and he would show up with new Adidas cleats for the team.  They would ask for Nikes, and he would show up having bought Nikes for the entire team.  They needed new jerseys, so he bought new jerseys for the team.  This was a really cool story.  Just beware, because the Sam Houston State Bearkats are also in the FCS playoff second round.  Should Coastal Carolina meet up with Sam Houston State, it will be in the championship game.  BE ON YOUR GUARD COACH MOGLIA!  THE BEARKATS ARE COMING FOR YOU!  DO YOU HEAR ME?

Like I said, the content was a little bit light this week on the show.  I don’t know if its because there is a light schedule of games today, or if it is because of the abundance of breakfast tacos which manifested themselves in front of me while watching.  I will not speculate on such things.  But I guess its time for the last official pick segment of the year on an official College Gameday edition.  This week’s guest picker was handsome man and Atlanta Falcon’s QB Matt Ryan.  Apparently Lee Corso did not know where the nickname Matty Ice came from, as he has never partaken in a nice tallboy of Natty Ice.  This went along well with Corso’s ignorance of Tupac Shakur from earlier.  Coach Corso made some great picks this morning, including picking “Calvin Klein” to beat Texas tonight, so take note gamblers.  Matty Ice went against the hometown crowd in Atlanta by picking Bama to win the big game tonight.  Herbie agreed and picked Bama as well.  Would Corso call for the upset?  Absolutely not, as he reminded us that Uga the bulldog is too ugly, so he has to go with Alabama and donned the elephant headgear.  Should be an exciting matchup, so enjoy this last regular edition of College Gameday.

Week 14 Headgear pick
Week 14 Headgear pick