My oh my, what a Saturday we had. Flashbacks to the great 2007 season of massive upsets coming out of nowhere. Did anybody predict both #1 and #2 would both go down within the span of an hour? No actually. Lou Holtz (3-2) is the only one who went out on a limb and picked Stanford over Oregon, which is strange because that was a much more likely upset than Baylor over KState. Did anybody actually think unranked Baylor could topple #1 KState? Yes. Todd McShay’s (3-2) upset special was Baylor over KState, and Desmond Howard (6-3) also went with the Golden Bears to pull the upset. This week’s guest picker Braden Pape also took Baylor to win, and posted a record of 6-5, so he might be better at singing that picking games. Still, maybe the best guest picker of the entire year. Lee Corso went 8-4, missing his headgear pick of Oregon obviously. Big winner this week were Kirk Herbstreit at 11-2 and Mike Bellotti at 7-2. I had to pull out the red pen quite a bit, and losers this week include Mark May (1-4), Colin Cowherd (2-4), and Robert Smith (4-7). Everyone else finished in between, so check below for the full report card and see how your favorite or most hated personality did.
Danny Kanell: 0-1
WRONG KState over Baylor
Dan Hawkins: 7-4
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG KState over Baylor
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Toledo over NIU
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT Clemson over NC St
RIGHT UCLA over USC
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
Charles Arbuckle: 3-2
RIGHT Bama over WCU
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
Mike Bellotti: 7-1
RIGHT S.Carolina over Wofford
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
RIGHT Florida over Jax St
RIGHT Miss St over Arkansas
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
Brock Huard: 0-1
WRONG KState over Baylor
Jason Sehorn: 2-0
RIGHT S.Carolina over Wofford
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
Tom Luginbill: 3-1
RIGHT S.Carolina over Wofford
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
WRONG Cinci over Rutgers
RIGHT Florida over Jax St
Ryen Russillo: 1-1
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Washington over Colorado
Mark May: 1-4
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
WRONG USC over UCLA
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
WRONG KState over Baylor
Lou Holtz: 3-2
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG USC over UCLA
Brian Griese: 1-2
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG USC over UCLA
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
Pat Forde: 21-6
RIGHT Clemson over NC St
RIGHT FSU over Maryland
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Mizzou over Syracuse
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
RIGHT Michigan over Iowa
RIGHT NW over Mich St
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT Kent St over BGSU
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT Oreg St over Cal
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Florida over Jax St
RIGHT Georgia over Ga So
RIGHT S.Carolina over Wofford
RIGHT Vanderbilt over Tennessee
RIGHT Bama over W.Carolina
RIGHT LSU over Ols Miss
RIGHT Miss St over Arkansas
WRONG KState over Baylor
RIGHT TAMU over SHSU
WRONG Utah over Arizona
WRONG Cinci over Rutgers
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
Mark Schlabach: 2-0
RIGHT Bama over W.Carolina
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
Trevor Matich: 5-2
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT LSU over Ole Miss
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Clemson over NC St
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Tennessee over Vanderbilt
WRONG KState over Baylor
Brad Edwards: 6-2
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT LSU over Ole Miss
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Clemson over NC St
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Vanderbilt over Tennessee
WRONG KState over Baylor
Colin Cowherd: 2-4
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
WRONG USC over UCLA
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT Notre Dame over Wake Forest
RIGHT LSU over Ole Miss
Robert Smith: 4-7
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG Cinci over Rutgers
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG USC over UCLA
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
WRONG Mizzou over Syracuse
WRONG Mich St over NW
WRONG UCF over Tulsa
Christian Fauria: 7-2
RIGHT UCLA over USC
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
RIGHT Rutgers over Cinci
RIGHT Syracuse over Mizzou
RIGHT NW over Mich St
RIGHT Kent St over BGSU
Mel Kiper Jr: 3-2
RIGHT Notre Dame over Wake Forest
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
Dari Nowkhah: 8-3
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
RIGHT Miss St over Arkansas
RIGHT S.Carolina over Wofford
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
RIGHT Bama over WCU
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
Todd McShay: 3-2
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT Notre Dame over Wake Forest
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Baylor over KState (upset special)
David Pollack: 3-3
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG KState over Baylor
WRONG USC over UCLA
Desmond Howard: 6-3
RIGHT ND over Wake Forest
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG LaTech over Utah St
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Baylor over KState
WRONG USC over UCLA
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
RIGHT Oregon St over Cal
RIGHT Lehigh over Lafayette
Chris Fowler: 0-1
WRONG LaTech over Utah St
Kirk Herbstreit: 11-2
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
RIGHT Notre Dame over Wake Forest
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Oregon St over Cal
RIGHT Lehigh over Lafayette
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT Rutgers over Cinci
RIGHT Vanderbilt over Tennessee
WRONG KState over Baylor
Lee Corso: 8-4
WRONG KState over Baylor
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Oregon St over Cal
RIGHT Lehigh over Lafayette
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT Rutgers over Cinci
RIGHT Vanderbilt over Tennessee
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
WRONG Oregon over Stanford (headgear pick)
Braden Pape: 6-5
RIGHT Lehigh over Lafayette
WRONG Yale over Harvard
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT UCLA over USC
WRONG Cinci over Rutgers
WRONG Tennessee over Vanderbilt
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
RIGHT Baylor over KState
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
Jennifer’s Picks: 10-4
RIGHT Clemson over NC St
RIGHT Boise St over CSU
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St (upset special)
WRONG USC over UCLA
RIGHT Oregon St over Cal
RIGHT Lehigh over Lafayette
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
RIGHT Utah St over LaTech
RIGHT Rutgers over Cinci
RIGHT Vanderbilt over Tennessee
WRONG KState over Baylor
RIGHT Okla St over TTU
WRONG Oregon over Stanford