We are getting a LATE start today on things because there was some official business to handle this morning. Don’t worry though, because we will be posting live all day as we play catch-up, the picks roll in, and other exciting things develop. Check back as we will be updating the live picks all morning and there will be a Gameday review coming shortly after.
Todd McShay:
Bama over TAMU
UCLA over Nebraska (upset special)
Lou Holtz:
TAMU over Bama
Nebraska over ucla
Texas over ole miss
Mark May:
Bama over TAMU
Ucla over Nebraska
Ole miss over texas
Chris Fallica:
Miss St over Auburn
Chris Fowler:
Auburn over Miss St
David Pollack:
Auburn over Miss St
Louisville over Kentucky
Oregon over Tennessee
Bama over TAMU
Desmond Howard:
TCU over TTU
Auburn over Miss St
Penn St over UCF
Notre Dame over Purdue
Ole Miss over Texas
Ariz St over Wisconsin
Ohio St over Cal
UCLA over Nebraska
Bama over TAMU
Kirk Herbstreit:
Oregon over Tennessee
Ohio st over Cal
TCU over TTU
Auburn over Miss St
Ole Miss over Texas
Wisconsin over Ariz St
BC over USC
UCLA over Nebraska
Iowa St over Iowa (upset special)
Washington over Illinois
TAMU over Bama
Lee Corso:
Texas over Ole Miss
Oregon over Tennessee
Ariz St over Wisconsin
Ohio St over Cal
USC over BC
Nebraska over UCLA
UCF over Penn St (upset special)
Auburn over Miss St
Washington over Illinois
Bama over TAMU (headgear pick)
Lyle Lovett:
Vanderbilt over S.Carolina (upset special)
Auburn over Miss St
Nebraska over UCLA
Washington over Illinois
Ariz St over Wisconsin
USC over BC
Ole Miss over Texas
TAMU over Bama
Jennifer’s Picks:
Boise St over AF
Auburn over Miss St
Michigan over Akron
Notre Dame over Purdue
Ohio St over Cal
UCLA over Nebraska
Washington over Illinois
Wisconsin over Ariz St
USC over BC
Ole Miss over Texas
TAMU over Bama (upset special)
It was a tough week this week to be a college football expert making picks. However, I’m sure all of you guys sitting at home got Georgia beating South Carolina, Miami beating Florida, BYU beating Texas, and Washington St beating USC. Our winner this week is Desmond Howard (6-0), and other notable performances were Jason Sehorn (7-3), and Jennifer (10-3). Billy the Cat and Lee Corso both got the headgear pick wrong going with South Carolina over Georgia, so both are now 0-2 on the year. Losers this week include Lee Corso (2-5), Trevor Matich (0-3), Ryen Russillo (0-3), Todd McShay (2-3), and Mel Kiper Jr. (2-3). Maybe we will turn things around next week guys. As always, the winner certificates are in the mail with a coupon for a free Blizzard from DQ as your prize. Check out things below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week, and check the Hall of Champions for the all-time standings.
Tom Luginbill: 1-0
RIGHT TAMU over SHSU
Kevin Carter: 0-1
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
Jason Sehorn: 7-3
RIGHT BC over Wake Forest
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Tennessee over W.Kentucky
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
RIGHT NW over Syracuse
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
WRONG USC over Wash St
RIGHT Stanford over SJSU
Pat Forde: 27-8
WRONG Wake Forest over Boston College
RIGHT UCF over FIU
RIGHT Clemson over SC St
RIGHT Oregon over UVA
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Houston over Temple
RIGHT Nebraska over USM
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Cinci over Illinois
WRONG Indiana over Navy
RIGHT Michigan over ND
RIGHT NW over Syracuse
RIGHT Ohio St over SDSU
RIGHT Wisconsin over Tennessee Tech
RIGHT Arizona over UNLV
WRONG JMU over Akron
RIGHT Ball St over Army
RIGHT BGSU over Kent St
WRONG USC over Wash St
RIGHT Stanford over SJSU
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
RIGHT Kentucky over Miami OH
RIGHT LSU over UAB
RIGHT Baylor over Buffalo
RIGHT TAMU over SHSU
RIGHT TCU over SE La
RIGHT Utah St over AF
WRONG Texas over BYU
WRONG UTEP over UNM
RIGHT Wyoming over Idaho
RIGHT Louisville over EKU
RIGHT Duke over Memphis
RIGHT UL Monroe over Grambling
RIGHT Troy over Savannah St
RIGHT Okla St over UTSA
Colin Cowherd: 6-3
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Oregon over UVA
RIGHT Ohio St over SDSU
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
RIGHT NW over Syracuse
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
WRONG USC over Wash St
Ryen Russillo: 0-3
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
WRONG Notre Dame over Michigan
Brad Edwards: 1-2
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia (upset special)
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
Mark Schlabach: 2-2
WRONG Florida over Miami FL
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
WRONG W.Kentucky over Tennessee (upset special)
Todd McShay: 2-3
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Oklahoma over WVU
WRONG WKU over Tennessee (upset special)
Trevor Matich: 0-3
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
WRONG Notre Dame over Michigan
Robert Smith: 1-3
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
Mark May: 1-0
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
Lou Holtz: 0-1
WRONG Notre Dame over Michigan
Dari Nowkhah: 2-3
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
RIGHT Oregon over UVA
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG Texas over BYU
Mel Kiper Jr.: 2-3
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
RIGIHT Michigan over Notre Dame
RIGHT Oregon over UVA
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG Texas over BYU
Chris Fallica: 0-1
WRONG Notre Dame over Michigan
David Pollack: 0-2
WRONG Notre Dame over Michigan
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
Chris Fowler: 1-0
RIGHT TAMU over SHSU
Desmond Howard: 6-0
RIGHT OU over WVU
RIGHT NW over Syracuse
RIGHT Tennessee over WKU
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
RIGHT Arizona over UNLV
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
Kirk Herbstreit: 4-4
RIGHT TAMU over SHSU
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
RIGHT Oregon over UVA
WRONG USC over Wash St
WRONG Indiana over Navy
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT Arizona over UNLV
Lee Corso: 2-5
RIGHT Stanford over SJSU
WRONG S.Carolina over Georgia
WRONG Indiana over Navy
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT Arizona over UNLV
WRONG Notre Dame over Michigan (headgear pick)
Mark Harmon: 3-3
WRONG Indiana over Navy
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT Arizona over UNLV
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
Jennifer’s Picks: 10-3
RIGHT Stanford over SJSU
RIGHT OU over WVU
WRONG Texas over BYU
RIGHT NW over Syracuse
RIGHT Tennessee over WKU
WRONG Indiana over Navy
WRONG Florida over Miami Fl
RIGHT Georgia over S.Carolina (upset special)
RIGHT Arizona over UNLV
RIGHT Oregon over UVA
RIGHT Clemson over SC St
RIGHT Boise St over Tenn Martin
RIGHT Michigan over Notre Dame
Welcome back to another great Saturday of college football folks. The afternoon games are in full swing, and that means it is time for another College Gameday review. This week the show was broadcasting from Ann Arbor, Michigan for the big matchup between Notre Dame and Michigan; THE LAST TIME THESE TWO TEAMS WILL EVER MEET*! The show opened up at 8AM central, for what is supposed to be this year’s normal schedule of a three hour show on ESPN every week. The crowd wasn’t exactly the biggest I’ve seen, and wasn’t as big as Clemson/Georgia last week either. I expected a little bit better from these two schools. Its too bad they will NEVER MEET AGAIN TO PLAY FOOTBALL.
*Last time they will meet as advertised by ESPN, unless both schools decide that they like money in which case the series will resume
The show opened with Fowler, Corso, Herbstreit, and Howard at the main desk, to be joined later by Sam Ponder and David Pollack. Fowler had an early hundred dollar question for the group: What was the trophy called that Florida and Miami(Fl) used to play for once upon a time decades ago? The confusing answer is the Seminole War Canoe, and the hundred dollar bill remained unclaimed. Early in the show we also had the return of everyone’s favorite segment, DAVID POLLACK USING THE INTERNET!!!!
David Pollack: Internet user
He was live Tweeting from the Michigan locker room where there is apparently a shrine to Desmond Howard. He answered about two tweets live before giving up and going back to the TV set. As the guys started breaking down matchups today, Lee Corso reiterated his bold claim that Stanford would win the championship this year, and they would make quick work of SJSU today. We were then joined by Samantha Ponder who had on another nice dress today. Jennifer predicts this will be the year of the dress with the belt to define her waistline (belt not pictured below; hidden by note cards). Other notes include that she parted her hair down the middle, and her wedding ring (courtesy of Christian Ponder) is absolutely huge.
Samantha Ponder, Week 2
We got an interview with Brady Hoke, and the main highlight was when Hoke declared that one John “Football” Manziel would ride the bench behind Devin Gardner if he played for Michigan. Alright then. There was a very strange segment featuring noted cellar-dweller (at least in my rankings) Mike Greenberg, of Mike & Mike in the Morning fame. Being a notable Northwestern grad, he was invited on campus to be an honorary team captain for today’s game against Syracuse. Highlights included Pat Fitzgerald not having time for this nonsense, Greenberg searching in many wrong places for the team’s offense meeting, and concluded with a goofy inspirational speech from the honorary captain. I found this segment to be unsuccessful, as it included far too much of Greenberg’s sarcastic, overly-dry, self-deprecating humor. And that is coming from someone who is full of unsuccessful, sarcastic, overly-dry, self-deprecating humor. Greenberg needs to stick to his radio show talking the Jets and Tebow every week and stay away from my Gameday broadcasts.
One of the funniest moments of the show was early on when Kirk Herbstreit started an extended speech breaking down some matchup from today, the Michigan band immediately began blaring music behind him and completely drowning him out. Intentional or not, it was quite hilarious.
I happened to notice something peculiar today. Chris Fowler was suspiciously QUITE interested in what the “experts” out in “the desert” thought about how “today’s underdogs” would “perform” against how they were “expected” to. Let me remind you that College Gameday endorses gambling in no way, shape, or form. Neither does Brent Musberger. Other Fowler notes include the fact that he continues to rag on Sam Houston State (who is playing some team from College Station with some guy that won some award last year). Keep it up Fowler, the Bearkat faithful do not forget these things.
George Whitfield Jr., quarterback extraordinaire, was interviewed again this week, and said more generic things about Johnny Football. This would be a cool segment if he went in-depth about how he sees things, but when it is so generic it is quite bland.
There was a GREAT piece by Tom Rinaldi this week about Tulane’s Devon Walker, who was paralyzed last year in a game against Tulsa. I remember seeing that game last year, and it was quite intense to be seeing it live. He wasn’t breathing on the field, and they were performing chest compressions to basically resuscitate him on the field before transferring him to a hospital. He is now paralyzed from the shoulders down, confined to a wheelchair, and is in intensive rehab. He vowed to be back on the sidelines this year to cheer on the team, and he made it. He spoke to the team before their first game this year, and the best moment of the whole segment was when they presented him with his own Tulane jersey to wear. His face absolutely lit up as they put the jersey on him. Nobody likes to give Tom Rinaldi a hard time more than he for how he tries to make stories overly emotional, but this one was absolutely fantastic, and if it can be found on Youtube or elsewhere, I highly recommend it.
Moving along, that story was followed by a piece by Gene Wojciechowski about Jadaveon Clowney from South Carolina. He went to Athens to find out how he could stop Clowney in today’s game. He polled the students on campus, and they seemed incredibly educated on football (especially the ones who said he is not a threat in this game tonight). He went around the town finding out more information about how to stop Clowney, including some possibly drunk guy tackling a cardboard cutout of Clowney. Then he interviewed some local Pop Warner players about how to stop Clowney, and they probably had the best insight of anyone interviewed. The end was pretty cute when about ten of them tackled the Clowney cutout. This segment also featured a cameo by David Pollack, who had a thing or two to say when one student said linebackers were nothing to be feared.
At this point, let’s take a moment to highlight the sign of the day. It was a slow day for signs, so the following sign is presented without comment:
Week 2: Sign of the Day
There was a new segment featuring Samantha Ponder interviewing Devin Gardner including her own new snazzy animated intro. Apparently Gardner likes cartoons, Brady Hoke looks like Fred Flintstone, and they talked about some other stuff. Other notes from today’s show include David Pollack shocking the world by picking AGAINST Georgia in today’s big game against South Carolina. Somewhere the REAL David Pollack is tied up in a closet and this look-alike is soiling the good name of a noted Georgia homer. Also, Michigan still hates Rich Rodriguez judging by the boos every time Arizona was mentioned today. Michigan also hates Herbie, and loves Desmond Howard.
But now, for the real reason you came here. It came time to pick the games. Today’s special guest celebrity picker (incredibly hyped on Twitter) was Mark Harmon from NCIS. His father, Tom Harmon, is a former Michigan Heisman winner from 1940, and Mark spent some time playing at UCLA himself. This sounded like a great segment in the making, and quickly turned into the most boring celebrity guest picker in the history of College Gameday. Mark Harmon picked six games, and said six words. Indiana. Florida. Georgia. Texas. Arizona. Michigan. End segment. No analysis. No jokes. No humor. End segment. Onto the headgear pick. I predicted this year Corso would have live animals on set at least four times this year, and thought this week was going to be a loser. How on earth would be bring a live animal on set today? A wolverine would be dangerous, and a drunk Irishman doesn’t count. Corso started poking the crowd with a stick hyping up Michigan, and before you knew it, he put in a leprechaun hat and proceeded to fill the desk with live chickens (in reference to Notre Dame chickening out in this series). Herbie looked terrified as usual, and it was a really funny way to end today’s episode. Enjoy the rest of your day folks.