Week 8 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Vanderbilt-2.5 vs LSU
Duke-3.5 vs Georgia Tech
Purdue+3.5 vs Northwestern

Screenshot

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: UNLV+12.5
Desmond Howard: Southern Cal+9.5
Stanford Steve: South Carolina+4.5
Pat McAfee: SMU+5.5
Nick Saban: Washington+4.5
Rece Davis: Washington State+17.5

Celebrity guest Jelly Roll:

BYU over Utah
Notre Dame over Southern Cal
Tennessee over Alabama
Texas Tech over Arizona State
Georgia over Ole Miss
Vanderbilt over LSU
Michigan over Washington
Georgia Tech over Duke

Kirk Herbstreit:

BYU over Utah
Notre Dame over Southern Cal
Alabama over Tennessee
Texas Tech over Arizona State
Vanderbilt over LSU
Michigan over Washington
Georgia Tech over Duke

Desmond Howard:

BYU over Utah
Southern Cal over Notre Dame
Alabama over Tennessee
Texas Tech over Arizona State
Georgia over Ole Miss
Vanderbilt over LSU
Michigan over Washington
Georgia Tech over Duke

Pat McAfee:

BYU over Utah
Notre Dame over Southern Cal
Alabama over Tennessee
Texas Tech over Arizona State
Georgia over Ole Miss
Vanderbilt over LSU
Michigan over Washington
Georgia Tech over Duke

Nick Saban:

Utah over BYU
Notre Dame over Southern Cal
Alabama over Tennessee
Texas Tech over Arizona State
Georgia over Ole Miss
LSU over Vanderbilt
Washington over Michigan
Georgia Tech over Duke

Week 2 2025: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 2 of our 2025 college football season is in the books and the picks from our college football analysts are graded. As a reminder, these are straight up picks from college football analysts; not gambling picks.

Winners this week include Chip Patterson (21-2), David Hale (7-1), and Tom Fornelli/Richard Johnson (20-3). However, I’m giving this week’s win to Rece Davis for going 6-0 on his picks on the College Gameday podcast this week.

This was our first official week with no Lee Corso, so there’s sadly nothing to report on headgear picks going forward. Kirk Herbstreit went 4-3. Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee and Nick Saban went 4-4. Celebrity guest picker Trae Young, making his second guest picker appearance, went 5-3 on his picks this week.

Check out the full results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

NamePctWinLoss
Rece_Davis10060
Joel_Klatt10050
Andy_Staples10040
Steve_Coughlin10030
Dusty_Dvoracek10020
Paul_Finebaum10010
Roman_Harper10010
Mark_Ingram10010
Matt_Leinart10010
Brett_McMurphy10010
Urban_Meyer10010
Brady_Quinn10010
Jordan_Rodgers10010
Ryen_Russillo10010
Tim_Tebow10010
Chip_Patterson91.3212
David_Hale87.571
Tom_Fornelli86.96203
Richard_Johnson86.96203
Danny_Kanell85173
Josh_Pate83.3351
Shehan_Jeyarajah82.61194
Pat_Forde7531
Andrea_Adelson73.33114
Greg_McElroy71.4352
Pete_Thamel66.6742
Chris_Fallica66.6721
JD_Pickell66.6721
Celebrity_Guest62.553
Kirk_Herbstreit57.1443
Aaron_Taylor55.5654
David_Pollack5055
Desmond_Howard5044
Nick_Saban5044
Pat_McAfee5044
Jennifer5044
Eric_Mac_Lain5022
Phil_Steele5011
Randy_Cross44.4445
Brian_Jones44.4445
Rick_Neuheisel37.535
Average73.6321577

Week 7 2024: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dog picks, celebrity guests, Stanford Steve’s Board and more!

Corso it out again this week, so there is no headgear pick.

Screenshot

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Illinois-23.5 vs Purdue
Penn State-3.5 vs Southern Cal
Ohio State-3 vs Oregon

Super Dog Picks:
Lee Corso: North Carolina+4.5 vs Georgia Tech
Kirk Herbstreit: Virginia+7.5 vs Louisville
Desmond Howard: Vanderbilt+12.5 vs Kentucky
Stanford Steve: South Florida+9 vs Memphis
Pat McAfee: Oklahoma+17 vs Texas
Nick Saban: Vanderbilt+12.5 vs Kentucky
Rece Davis: Buffalo+10.5 vs Toledo

Celebrity guest Kaitlin Olson:

Colorado over Kansas State
Iowa State over West Virginia
Ole Miss over LSU
Oregon over Ohio State
Tennessee over Florida
Arizona over BYU
Texas over Oklahoma
California over Pittsburgh
Penn State over Southern Cal
Iowa over Washington

Kirk Herbstreit:

Colorado over Kansas State
Iowa State over West Virginia
LSU over Ole Miss
Ohio State over Oregon
Tennessee over Florida
BYU over Arizona
California over Pittsburgh
Penn State over Southern Cal
Iowa over Washington

Desmond Howard:

Colorado over Kansas State
Iowa State over West Virginia
LSU over Ole Miss
Oregon over Ohio State
Tennessee over Florida
BYU over Arizona
Texas over Oklahoma
Pittsburgh over California
Penn State over Southern Cal
Iowa over Washington

Pat McAfee:

Colorado over Kansas State
West Virginia over Iowa State
Ole Miss over LSU
Oregon over Ohio State
Tennessee over Florida
BYU over Arizona
Texas over Oklahoma
Pittsburgh over California
Penn State over Southern Cal
Iowa over Washington

Nick Saban:

Colorado over Kansas State
Iowa State over West Virginia
Ole Miss over LSU
Ohio State over Oregon
Tennessee over Florida
BYU over Arizona
Texas over Oklahoma
Pittsburgh over California
Penn State over Southern Cal
Iowa over Washington