Week 12 2025: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 12 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded.

Celebrity guest picker Aaron Donald went 6-3 picking games on College Gameday this week. Kirk Herbstreit went 6-2. Pat McAfee and Nick Saban went 5-4, with Desmond Howard bringing up the rear at 4-5.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

NamePctWinLoss
Steve_Coughlin10040
Chip_Patterson90182
Tom_Fornelli89.47172
David_Hale85.7161
Dusty_Dvoracek83.3351
JD_Pickell83.3351
Greg_McElroy81.8292
Paul_Finebaum8041
Kirk_Herbstreit7562
Danny_Kanell7531
Josh_Pate7531
Jordan_Rodgers7531
Ralph_Russo7531
Richard_Johnson72.73166
Shehan_Jeyarajah68.42136
Celebrity_Guest66.6763
Joel_Klatt66.6742
Phil_Steele66.6721
Andy_Staples62.553
Rece_Davis6032
Bruce_Feldman6032
Pat_Forde6032
Roman_Harper6032
Stewart_Mandel6032
Andrea_Adelson57.1443
Nick_Saban55.5654
Pat_McAfee55.5654
Brian_Jones55.5654
Rick_Neuheisel55.5654
Aaron_Taylor5055
Chris_Fallica5011
Desmond_Howard44.4445
Randy_Cross44.4445
David_Pollack4046
Pete_Thamel4023
Tim_Tebow4023
Jennifer33.3336
Average66.22196100