Week 12 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dogs, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
BYU-3.5 vs TCU
Illinois-14.5 vs Maryland
Notre Dame vs Pitt over 54

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Baylor+9.5
Desmond Howard: Pitt+12.5
Stanford Steve: Tennessee Tech+22.5
Pat McAfee: WVU+10.5
Nick Saban: Navy+9.5
Rece Davis: Utah State+6.5

Celebrity guest Aaron Donald:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Southern Cal over Iowa
Virginia over Duke
Alabama over Oklahoma
Arizona State over West Virginia
Pittsburgh over Notre Dame
Navy over South Florida
Cincinnati over Arizona

Kirk Herbstreit:
TCU over BYU
Southern Cal over Iowa
Virginia over Duke
Oklahoma over Alabama
Arizona State over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Pittsburgh
South Florida over Navy
Arizona over Cincinnati

Desmond Howard:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Southern Cal over Iowa
Duke over Virginia
Alabama over Oklahoma
Arizona State over West Virginia
Pittsburgh over Notre Dame
South Florida over Navy
Cincinnati over Arizona

Pat McAfee:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Iowa over Southern Cal
Duke over Virginia
Oklahoma over Alabama
West Virginia over Arizona State
Notre Dame over Pittsburgh
Navy over South Florida
Cincinnati over Arizona

Nick Saban:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Southern Cal over Iowa
Duke over Virginia
Alabama over Oklahoma
Arizona State over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Pittsburgh
South Florida over Navy
Cincinnati over Arizona

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 56-18 (75.68%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Week 10 2025: CFB analysts picks are graded; results are in!

Week 10 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded. Let’s jump right in.

Celebrity guest picker Alex Smith went 5-3 on College Gameday this week (not counting his pick against the spread, because I’m not sure how I’m going to tally those yet). Nick Saban and Pat McAfee also went 5-3. Desmond Howard went 4-4. Kirk Herbstreit went 3-4 on his picks to bring up the rear.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

NamePctWinLoss
Dusty_Dvoracek10040
Phil_Steele10040
Todd_McShay10010
Greg_McElroy85.7161
Richard_Johnson75124
Chris_Fallica7531
Joel_Klatt7531
Tom_Fornelli72.22135
Shehan_Jeyarajah70.59125
Rece_Davis66.6742
Andy_Staples66.6742
Pat_Forde66.6721
Nick_Saban62.553
Pat_McAfee62.553
Jennifer62.553
Celebrity_Guest62.553
Josh_Pate62.553
Chip_Patterson55.56108
Andrea_Adelson55.5654
David_Hale55.5654
Desmond_Howard5044
Danny_Kanell5033
Pete_Thamel5033
JD_Pickell5011
David_Pollack45.4556
Brian_Jones44.4445
Rick_Neuheisel44.4445
Aaron_Taylor44.4445
Kirk_Herbstreit42.8634
Randy_Cross33.3336
Steve_Coughlin001
Average60.4914796

Week 10 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dogs, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
California+6.5 vs Virginia
Vanderbilt+3.5 vs Texas
Cincinnati+10.5 vs Utah

Screenshot

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: NC State+5.5
Desmond Howard: Cincinnati+10.5
Stanford Steve: Kansas State+7.5
Pat McAfee: Navy+6.5
Nick Saban: SMU+9.5
Rece Davis: California+5.5

Celebrity guest Alex Smith:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Oklahoma over Tennessee
Nebraska over Southern Cal
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Texas over Vanderbilt
Navy over North Texas
Air Force over Army

Kirk Herbstreit:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Cincinnati over Utah
Nebraska over Southern Cal
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Vanderbilt over Texas
Navy over North Texas
Army over Air Force

Desmond Howard:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Tennessee over Oklahoma
Southern Cal over Nebraska
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Vanderbilt over Texas
Navy over North Texas
Air Force over Army

Pat McAfee:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Oklahoma over Tennessee
Nebraska over Southern Cal
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Vanderbilt over Texas
Navy over North Texas
Army over Air Force

Nick Saban:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Tennessee over Oklahoma
Southern Cal over Nebraska
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Texas over Vanderbilt
Navy over North Texas
Air Force over Army