Week 6 2013: College Gameday review!

It may be late, and it may be brief, but don’t worry, the weekly College Gameday review is here.  Today’s edition of Colege Gameday was broadcasting live from Evanston, Illinois for the big matchup between Ohio State and Northwestern.  This is the first time Gameday has been at Northwestern since 1995, so it is a rare occasion that Northwestern is good at football, and even rarer for Gameday to make an appearance.

The first thing we noticed this morning, and if you are as obsessed with Gameday as we are maybe you noticed too, was that noted country rapping sensation Cowboy Troy’s rap solo was cut from this morning’s Gameday intro.  What’s up with that?  How am I supposed to get jacked up without a black guy in a cowboy hat rapping football lyrics at me?

Anyways, we got an early dose of Samantha Ponder, and I can’t help but notice her role has been reduced in recent weeks.  I wonder what the deal is with that.  The people demand more Samantha Ponder and Cowboy Troy.  Mrs. Ponder’s outfit this week was better than last week’s but still questionable.  The jacket was not well received by those polled this morning (Jennifer).

Who picked out my jacket?
Who picked out my jacket?

Tom Rinaldi had an early piece this morning.  One was about all of the geniuses attending Northwestern who also play football.  It is pretty impressive, but even more impressive was how incredibly moving Tom Rinaldi makes it to watch someone sharpen a pencil by hand up close in slow motion while soft-talking.  We didn’t get any beatnik poetry from him so that makes me sad.  I NEED INSPIRATION!!!

We got a great dose of TODD MCSHAY LOOKIN’ AT THE TAPE!!! He was hanging out with Urban Meyer and Braxton Miller in the film room talking about mechanics.  Todd McShay is impressed with both his natural athleticism (which netted him the Big 10 Offensive Player of the Year last year) as well as his improved mechanics.  I wish just once we’d get a piece where Todd McShay sits with an athlete to look at the tape, and then rip the kid a new one about sloppy mechanics or a lack of effort.  I like to imagine that is what he is like leading up to the NFL draft where he is locked in a dark room ranting and raving 22 hours a day about mechanics, effort, heart and intangibles.

We had a return from QB Guru George Whitfield again.  At least this week we got to see more training film with him and Braxton Miller where they were having Miller throw a football while sitting in a chair against a defender with a broom or something.  The unusual training footage is pretty interesting.  The generic positive assessment of Whitfield about his paying clients?  Not so much.

The most exciting piece today was a callback to last week’s piece about the history of Gameday signs.  Last week they talked about how the first guy to bring a sign to Gameday was some unknown guy with a sign nobody could read.  Well believe it or not, they dug up this guy named Bob Merced and had him recreate the sign and flew his ass out to Gameday this morning which was really cool.

Bob Merced: Original sign guy
Bob Merced: Original sign guy

Speaking of signs, here is the sign of the day!

Week 6 Sign of the week!
Week 6 Sign of the week!

So let’s review.  No Cowboy Troy.  Less Samantha Ponder.  No Bald Man on Campus.  No David Pollack using the internet.  No Tom Rinaldi beatnik poetry.  Sign creativity was lacking aside from the one pictured above.  It was all-in-all a pretty mediocre episode.  Who could possibly save it as a guest celebrity picker?  How about the ORIGINAL football picker, one Mr. Brent Musberger.  He was so excited to be there at Gameday being a Northwestern alum.  I haven’t confirmed this, but I am fairly confident he was going no-pants behind the desk, and was all too happy to share his picks for who was going to win, who was going to cover the spread, and which totals to bet.  Of course, ESPN, Brent Musberger,  and Cole’s Gameday blog in no way endorse any form of gambling.  As Colin Cowherd would say, “this isn’t for making money; that’s called a job”.  Anyways, the guys picked a ton of games today, which excited me.  Brent and Herbie couldn’t pick the big game tonight since they are calling it, but I have a feeling which way Brent was leaning.  Billy the Cat picked Ohio State over Northwestern, and Lee Corso went with the Buckeyes too!  Either way, Corso and our cat will be tied going into next week, when we will hopefully see more exciting picks to determine who can pick the headgear game better between the two of them.  Goodnight folks.

Billy picks Ohio State!
Billy picks Ohio State!
Corso goes with Buckeyes!
Corso goes with Buckeyes!

Week 6 2013: Saturday morning Gameday picks! #saturdayselections

I’d like to wish you a happy Saturday morning.  This week has some solid matchups and some solid picks coming in from our experts.  We are starting off this morning with some late additions from last night, and will be updating all morning with more from your favorite analysts including Lee Corso’s headgear pick, Gameday celebrity guests, a little Dari and Mel, and hopefully Todd McShay.

Ryen Russillo:
Mich St over Iowa
Stanford over Washington

Mark May:
Ohio St over NW
FSU over Maryland
Florida over Arkansas
Stanford over Washington
Ariz St over Notre Dame

Lou Holtz:
Fsu over Maryland
Washington over Stanford
Ohio St over NW
Notre Dame over Ariz St

Robert Smith:
Fsu over Maryland
GaTech over Miami Fl
Ole Miss over Auburn
Stanford over Washington
Ohio St over NW
Ariz st over ND

Jason Sehorn:
Washington over Stanford
Ohio St over NW
Fsu over Maryland
Ariz st over Notre Dame
Auburn over Ole Miss
NDSU over N Iowa
Navy over AF
Okla st over KState
Mich St over Iowa
Miami Fl over GaTech

Dari Nowkhah:
NDSU over N Iowa
Navy over AF
Okla st over KState
Iowa over Mich St
Miami Fl over GaTech
Auburn over Ole Miss
Ariz st over Notre Dame
Maryland over fsu
Stanford over Washington
Ohio St over NW

Mel Kiper Jr.:
Ohio St over NW
Stanford over Washington
FSU over Maryland
Miami Fl over GaTech
Ariz St over Notre Dame

Paul Finebaum:
NW over Ohio St

Todd McShay:
Ohio St over NW
Stanford over Washington
FSU over Maryland
Notre Dame over Ariz St (upset special)

Skip Bayless:
Ohio St over NW

Pat Forde:
Utah St over BYU
FSU over Maryland
UVA over Ball St
NC St over Wake Forest
Miami Fl over GaTech
Clemson over Syracuse
Louisville over Temple
VaTech over UNC
Oregon over Colorado
TTU over Kansas
OU over TCU
Okla St over KState
Indiana over Penn St
Iowa over Mich St
Michigan over Minnesota
Ohio St over NW
Stanford over Washington
Florida over Arkansas
S.Carolina over Kentucky
Georgia over Tennessee
Bama over Georgia St
Ole Miss over Auburn
LSU over Miss St
Baylor over WVU
Notre Dame over Ariz St
S.Miss over FIU
Fresno St over Idaho

David Pollack:
OU over TCU
Ohio St over NW

Desmond Howard:
Miami Fl over GaTech
Ariz St over Notre Dame
AF over Navy
OU over TCU
Okla St over KState
Stanford over Washington
Ohio St over NW
FSU over Marlaynd

Kirk Herbstreit:
UCLA over Utah
ASU over ND
Texas over Iowa St
Ucla over Utah
Fsu over Maryland
Ariz St over Notre Dame
Georgia over Tennessee
Miami Fl over GaTech
Mich St over Iowa
Ole miss over Auburn
Navy over AF
Okla St over KState
Stanford over Washington
Ball St over Virginia (upset special)
NDSU over N Iowa
S.Miss over FIU
Indiana over Penn St
LSU over Miss St
Vanderbilt over Mizzou

Lee Corso:
Navy over AF
Auburn over Ole Miss
OU over TCU
Baylor over WVU
Okla St over KState
Stanford over Washington
FSU over Maryland
Hawaii over SJSU (upset special)
NDSU over N Iowa
S.Miss over FIU
Penn St over Indiana
Iowa over Mich St
Ariz St over Notre Dame
LSU over Miss St
Mizzou over Vanderbilt
Ohio St over NW (headgear pick)

Brent Musberger:
Akron over Ohio (upset special)
N Iowa over NDSU
S.Miss over FIU
Indiana over Penn St
Iowa over Mich St (AND the under)
Ariz St over Notre Dame
Stanford over Washington
Auburn over Ole Miss
LSU over Miss St
Vanderbilt over Mizzou

Mike Greenberg:
NW over Ohio St

Jennifer’s Picks:
Clemson over Syracuse
Navy over AF
Baylor over WVU
Okla St over KState
Stanford over Washington
NDSU over N Iowa
S.Miss over FIU
Penn St over Indiana
Mich St over Iowa
Ariz St over Notre Dame
Auburn over Ole Miss (upset special)
LSU over Miss St
Vanderbilt over Mizzou
Ohio St over NW

Week 5 2013: Results are in!

Week 5 was a big week with tons of picks from lots of experts.  I guess that happens when there’s significant games going on.  The biggest stumbling block this week from our experts was the Oklahoma St/WVU game.  Nobody that picked that game got it right.  Due to that fact, our winner this week is Gameday celebrity picker Bubba Watson, who went undefeated at 10-0 (but didn’t pick the OKSt/WVU game).  Jennifer came in at an impressive 13-1, and will share this week’s victory with Bubba Watson.  Other winners include Colin Cowherd (9-2), Charlie Arbuckle (8-2), and Dari Nowkhah (8-2).  Losers this week are Desmond Howard (3-4), and Brian Griese (2-3).  Corso lost his headgear pick going with LSU.  Billy the Cat won by picking Georgia.  They are both tied at 2-3 on the year, so its a good race to see who can pick big games better.  Commemorative fruit baskets have been mailed to this week’s winners along with their certificates.  Check out below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

Colin Cowherd: 9-2
WRONG Okla St over WVU
RIGHT Miami Fl over USF
RIGHT Georgia over LSU
WRONG Notre Dame over OU
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Washington over Arizona
RIGHT Florida over Kentucky
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
RIGHT Ariz St over USC

Brad Edwards: 2-1
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St (upset special)
RIGHT OU over ND
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas

Paul Finebaum: 4-1
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Washington over Arizona
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame

Trevor Matich: 2-0
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT OU over ND

Robert Smith: 4-1
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St

Danny Kanell: 5-0
RIGHT Miami Fl over USF
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Georgia over LSU
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin

Mark May: 3-3
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG LSU over Georgia
WRONG USC over Ariz St
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Washington over Arizona

Lou Holtz: 3-2
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG Ole Miss over Bama
RIGHT Georgia over LSU
WRONG Notre Dame over OU
RIGHT Washington over Arizona

Brian Griese: 2-3
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
WRONG Notre Dame over OU
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT Ariz St over USC
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss

Woody Paige: 0-1
Ole Miss over Bama

Bll Plaschke: 1-0
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss

Scott Van Pelt: 0-1
WRONG Notre Dame over OU

Ryen Russillo: 2-1
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG Wyoming over Tx St

Mark Schlabach: 0-1
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St (upset special)

Skip Bayless: 3-0
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame

Charles Arbuckle: 8-2
RIGHT SDSU over NM St
RIGHT Iowa over Minnesota
WRONG USC over Ariz St
RIGHT Washington over Arizona
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG LSU over Georgia

Dari Nowkhah: 8-2
RIGHT SDSU over NM St
RIGHT Iowa over Minnesota
RIGHT Ariz St over USC
RIGHT Washington over Arizona
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG Wisconsin over Ohio St
WRONG LSU over Georgia

Mel Kiper Jr.: 4-1
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF

Pat Forde: 16-8
RIGHT Utah St over SJSU
RIGHT Clemson over Wake Forest
WRONG UNC over ECU
RIGHT FSU over BC
WRONG UVA over Pitt
WRONG Okla St over WVU
WRONG Minnesota over Iowa
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG Purdue over NIU
RIGHT Nevada over AF
RIGHT Ariz St over USC
RIGHT Oregon over Cal
RIGHT Washington over Arizona
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT Florida over Kentucky
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Fresno St over Hawaii
RIGHT UNLV over UNM
WRONG Notre Dame over OU
WRONG UConn over Buffalo
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
RIGHT Miami Fl over USF

Todd McShay: 3-2
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
WRONG LSU over Georgia
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG USC over Ariz St (upset special)

Chris Fallica: 1-1
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG Minnesota over Iowa

Chris Fowler: 1-1
WRONG Notre Dame over OU
RIGHT NIU over Purdue

David Pollack: 2-0
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Georgia over LSU

Desmond Howard: 3-4
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG Ole Miss over Bama
RIGHT Wash over Arizona
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
WRONG Purdue over NIU
WRONG LSU over Georgia
WRONG Okla St over WVU

Kirk herbstreit: 9-3
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Wash over Arizona
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
WRONG Purdue over NIU
WRONG USC over Ariz St
WRONG Okla St over WVU
RIGHT SHSU over EWU
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Iowa over Minnesota
RIGHT Georgia over LSU

Lee Corso: 8-5
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Wash over Arizona
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
RIGHT NIU over Purdue
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
WRONG Okla St over WVU
WRONG EWU over SHSU
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
WRONG Minnesota over Iowa
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
WRONG USC over Ariz St
WRONG LSU over Georgia (headgear pick)

Bubba Watson: 10-0
RIGHT SHSU over EWU
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Iowa over Minnesota
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Ariz St over USC
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
RIGHT Georgia over LSU

Willie Robertson: 6-4
RIGHT SHSU over EWU
WRONG UCF over S.Carolina
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
WRONG Ole Miss over Bama
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Iowa over Minnesota
WRONG Notre Dame over OU
RIGHT Ariz St over USC
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
WRONG LSU over Georgia

Jennifer’s Picks: 13-1
RIGHT Washington over Arizona
RIGHT Stanford over Wash St
RIGHT S.Carolina over UCF
WRONG Okla St over WVU
RIGHT Clemson over Wake Forest
RIGHT Boise St over USM
RIGHT SHSU over EWU
RIGHT TAMU over Arkansas
RIGHT Bama over Ole Miss (closer than the experts think)
RIGHT Iowa over Minnesota
RIGHT OU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Ariz St over USC
RIGHT Ohio St over Wisconsin
RIGHT Georgia over LSU (upset special)

Billy the Cat: 0-1
RIGHT Georgia over LSU