Week 4 2024: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

The week 4 grades are in from our esteemed panel of analysts. As a reminder, the analyst picks are straight up (not against the spread).

Lee Corso went 7-3 including a win with his headgear selection Tennessee over Oklahoma. Celebrity guest picker Blake Shelton seemed to have little interest in any of the games themselves, and came out with a 5-5 week to show for it. Desmond Howard went 7-3. Kirk Herbstreit went 6-3. Pat McAfee went 6-4. Nick Saban went 5-5 on the week. Everyone else is somewhere in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

NamePctWinLoss
Brett_McMurphy10040
Corso_Headgear10010
Paul_Finebaum10010
Roman_Harper10010
Jordan_Rodgers10010
Tim_Tebow10010
Scott_Van_Pelt10010
Tom_Fornelli84.21163
Josh_Pate83.3351
Shehan_Jeyarajah77.78144
Richard_Johnson77.78144
Pat_Forde7531
Dan_Mullen7531
Chip_Patterson73.68145
Andrea_Adelson72.7383
Dennis_Dodd72.22135
Pete_Thamel71.4352
Lee_Corso7073
Desmond_Howard7073
Jennifer7073
Steve_Coughlin7073
Kirk_Herbstreit66.6763
Andy_Staples66.6721
Phil_Steele66.6721
David_Hale63.6474
Pat_McAfee6064
Joel_Klatt6032
Dan_Wetzel6032
Rece_Davis57.1443
Rick_Neuheisel55.5654
Aaron_Taylor55.5654
Danny_Kanell54.5565
Nick_Saban5055
Celebrity_Guest5055
Ross_Dellenger5022
Dusty_Dvoracek5022
Chris_Fallica5022
Bruce_Feldman44.4445
Brian_Jones44.4445
Greg_McElroy4023
Randy_Cross37.535
Colin_Cowherd001
Average65.94211109

Week 4 2024: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Corso’s headgear, celebrity guests, Super Dog picks and more!

Corso’s Headgear: Tennessee over Oklahoma

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Penn State-48.5 vs Kent State
Virginia-3.5 vs Coastal Carolina
Florida State-2.5 vs California

Screenshot

Super Dog Picks:
Lee Corso: Michigan+4.5 vs Southern Cal
Kirk Herbstreit: South Florida+17 vs Miami FL
Desmond Howard: Marshall+40 vs Ohio State
Stanford Steve: Buffalo+13.5 vs Northern Illinois
Pat McAfee: NC State+19.5 vs Clemson
Nick Saban: Arkansas State+21 vs Iowa State
Rece Davis: Navy+8.5 vs Memphis

Lee Corso:

Kansas State over BYU
Boston College over Michigan State
Baylor over Colorado
Tennessee over Oklahoma
SMU over TCU
Utah over Oklahoma State
Arkansas over Auburn
Louisville over Georgia Tech
Michigan over Southern Cal
Virginia Tech over Rutgers

Celebrity guest Blake Shelton:

Kansas State over BYU
Boston College over Michigan State
Colorado over Baylor
Oklahoma over Tennessee
TCU over SMU
Oklahoma State over Utah
Arkansas over Auburn
Louisville over Georgia Tech
Michigan over Southern Cal
Virginia Tech over Rutgers

Kirk Herbstreit:

BYU over Kansas State
Boston College over Michigan State
Colorado over Baylor
TCU over SMU
Utah over Oklahoma State
Auburn over Arkansas
Louisville over Georgia Tech
Southern Cal over Michigan
Rutgers over Virginia Tech

Desmond Howard:

Kansas State over BYU
Boston College over Michigan State
Colorado over Baylor
Tennessee over Oklahoma
TCU over SMU
Utah over Oklahoma State
Arkansas over Auburn
Louisville over Georgia Tech
Southern Cal over Michigan
Rutgers over Virginia Tech

Pat McAfee:

Kansas State over BYU
Boston College over Michigan State
Colorado over Baylor
Tennessee over Oklahoma
SMU over TCU
Utah over Oklahoma State
Arkansas over Auburn
Georgia Tech over Louisville
Southern Cal over Michigan
Virginia Tech over Rutgers

Nick Saban:

Kansas State over BYU
Boston College over Michigan State
Colorado over Baylor
Tennessee over Oklahoma
TCU over SMU
Oklahoma State over Utah
Arkansas over Auburn
Louisville over Georgia Tech
Southern Cal over Michigan
Virginia Tech over Rutgers

Week 3 2024: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Corso’s headgear, super dog picks, celebrity guests and more!

Corso’s Headgear: LSU over South Carolina

Screenshot

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Washington State+5.5 vs Washington
Tennessee-49 vs Kent State
Florida+3 vs Texas A&M

Super Dog Picks:
Lee Corso: Wyoming+9.5 vs BYU
Kirk Herbstreit: Oregon State+17 vs Oregon
Desmond Howard: Louisiana Tech+20.5 vs NC St
Stanford Steve: Kennesaw St+18.5 vs San Jose St
Pat McAfee: Boston College+14.5 vs Missouri
Nick Saban: Toledo+10.5 vs Mississippi St
Rece Davis: North Texas+10 vs Texas Tech

Lee Corso:

Colorado over Colorado State
Florida over Texas A&M
Oklahoma over Tulane
Oregon over Oregon State
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Purdue
Washington over Washington State
Missouri over Boston College
Florida State over Memphis
Cincinnati over Miami (OH)
LSU over South Carolina
Alabama over Wisconsin

Celebrity guest Dawn Staley:

Colorado over Colorado State
Texas A&M over Florida
Oklahoma over Tulane
Oregon over Oregon State
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Purdue
Washington over Washington State
Boston College over Missouri
Memphis over Florida State
Cincinnati over Miami (OH)
South Carolina over LSU
Alabama over Wisconsin

Kirk Herbstreit:

Colorado State over Colorado
Texas A&M over Florida
Oklahoma over Tulane
Oregon over Oregon State
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Purdue
Washington State over Washington
Missouri over Boston College
Florida State over Memphis
Cincinnati over Miami (OH)
Alabama over Wisconsin

Desmond Howard:

Colorado State over Colorado
Florida over Texas A&M
Oklahoma over Tulane
Oregon over Oregon State
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Purdue
Washington over Washington State
Missouri over Boston College
Florida State over Memphis
Miami (OH) over Cincinnati
LSU over South Carolina
Alabama over Wisconsin

Pat McAfee:

Colorado over Colorado State
Texas A&M over Florida
Oklahoma over Tulane
Oregon over Oregon State
West Virginia over Pittsburgh
Purdue over Notre Dame
Washington over Washington State
Boston College over Missouri
Memphis over Florida State
Cincinnati over Miami (OH)
South Carolina over LSU
Alabama over Wisconsin

Nick Saban:

Colorado over Colorado State
Florida over Texas A&M
Oklahoma over Tulane
Oregon over Oregon State
West Virginia over Pittsburgh
Notre Dame over Purdue
Washington State over Washington
Missouri over Boston College
Memphis over Florida State
Miami (OH) over Cincinnati
LSU over South Carolina
Alabama over Wisconsin