Week 5 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Iowa State-4.5 vs Arizona
UCLA+6.5 vs Northwestern
Penn State-3.5 vs Oregon

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Colorado+6.5
Desmond Howard: Mississippi State+7.5
Stanford Steve: Auburn+7.5
Pat McAfee: Oklahoma State+21.5
Nick Saban: UCLA+6.5
Rece Davis: Syracuse+4.5

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 44-16 (73.33%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Celebrity guest LaVar Arrington:

Penn State over Oregon
Georgia over Alabama
Iowa State over Arizona
Tennessee over Mississippi State
Washington over Ohio State
Texas A&M over Auburn
Ole Miss over LSU
Iowa over Indiana
Southern Cal over Illinois
Notre Dame over Arkansas

Kirk Herbstreit:

Penn State over Oregon
Iowa State over Arizona
Tennessee over Mississippi State
Ohio State over Washington
Texas A&M over Auburn
LSU over Ole Miss
Indiana over Iowa
Southern Cal over Illinois
Notre Dame over Arkansas

Desmond Howard:

Oregon over Penn State
Georgia over Alabama
Iowa State over Arizona
Mississippi State over Tennessee
Ohio State over Washington
Texas A&M over Auburn
Ole Miss over LSU
Indiana over Iowa
Southern Cal over Illinois
Notre Dame over Arkansas

Pat McAfee:

Penn State over Oregon
Georgia over Alabama
Iowa State over Arizona
Tennessee over Mississippi State
Ohio State over Washington
Texas A&M over Auburn
Ole Miss over LSU
Indiana over Iowa
Illinois over Southern Cal
Notre Dame over Arkansas

Nick Saban:

Penn State over Oregon
Alabama over Georgia
Iowa State over Arizona
Tennessee over Mississippi State
Ohio State over Washington
Texas A&M over Auburn
LSU over Ole Miss
Indiana over Iowa
Southern Cal over Illinois
Notre Dame over Arkansas

Week 4 2025: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 5 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our esteemed panel of analysts are graded. Let’s jump right in.

Celebrity guest picker Matthew Tkachuk went 4-2. Kirk Herbstreit went 4-3. Desmond Howard went 3-3. Pat McAfee went 5-2 while Coach Saban went 6-2 on his picks. Everyone else is in the mix below so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

NamePctWinLoss
Steve_Coughlin10050
Matt_Leinart10010
Brett_McMurphy10010
Brady_Quinn10010
Chip_Patterson88.24152
Shehan_Jeyarajah87.5142
Richard_Johnson87.5142
Brian_Jones87.571
David_Pollack87.571
Aaron_Taylor87.571
Tom_Fornelli80123
Paul_Finebaum8041
Roman_Harper8041
Tim_Tebow8041
Nick_Saban7562
Randy_Cross7562
Rick_Neuheisel7562
Dusty_Dvoracek7531
Joel_Klatt7531
Josh_Pate7531
Pat_McAfee71.4352
Celebrity_Guest66.6742
Danny_Kanell66.6742
Andy_Staples66.6721
Jennifer62.553
Rece_Davis6032
Jordan_Rodgers6032
Pete_Thamel6032
Kirk_Herbstreit57.1443
Greg_McElroy57.1443
Desmond_Howard5033
Jimbo_Fisher5022
Eric_Mac_Lain5022
Chris_Fallica5011
Pat_Forde5011
Phil_Steele33.3312
Mark_Ingram001
Urban_Meyer001
Scott_Van_Pelt001
Average73.9117060

Week 4 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Florida State-44.5 vs Kent State
Oregon-33.5 vs Oregon State
Tulane+11.5 vs Ole Miss

Screenshot

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Illinois+6.5
Desmond Howard: Illinois+6.5
Stanford Steve: Wyoming+12.5
Pat McAfee: West Virginia+13.5
Nick Saban: Tulane+11.5
Rece Davis: Memphis+7.5

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 43-15 (74.14%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Celebrity guest Matthew Tkachuk:
Syracuse+17.5
Missouri-10.5
FSU-45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Illinois over Indiana
Oklahoma over Auburn
Michigan over Nebraska
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Kirk Herbstreit:
Clemson-17.5
South Carolina+10.5
FSU-45.5
Illinois over Indiana
Oklahoma over Auburn
Michigan over Nebraska
Florida State over Kent State
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU
Clemson over Syracuse

Desmond Howard:
Syracuse+17.5
South Carolina+10.5
Kent St+45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Illinois over Indiana
Auburn over Oklahoma
Michigan over Nebraska
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Pat McAfee:
Syracuse+17.5
South Carolina+10.5
FSU-45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Indiana over Illinois
Oklahoma over Auburn
Nebraska over Michigan
Florida State over Kent State
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Nick Saban:
Syracuse+17.5
Missouri-10.5
FSU-45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Illinois over Indiana
Missouri over South Carolina
Oklahoma over Auburn
Michigan over Nebraska
Florida State over Kent State
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU