Week 4 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Florida State-44.5 vs Kent State
Oregon-33.5 vs Oregon State
Tulane+11.5 vs Ole Miss

Screenshot

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Illinois+6.5
Desmond Howard: Illinois+6.5
Stanford Steve: Wyoming+12.5
Pat McAfee: West Virginia+13.5
Nick Saban: Tulane+11.5
Rece Davis: Memphis+7.5

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 43-15 (74.14%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Celebrity guest Matthew Tkachuk:
Syracuse+17.5
Missouri-10.5
FSU-45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Illinois over Indiana
Oklahoma over Auburn
Michigan over Nebraska
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Kirk Herbstreit:
Clemson-17.5
South Carolina+10.5
FSU-45.5
Illinois over Indiana
Oklahoma over Auburn
Michigan over Nebraska
Florida State over Kent State
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU
Clemson over Syracuse

Desmond Howard:
Syracuse+17.5
South Carolina+10.5
Kent St+45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Illinois over Indiana
Auburn over Oklahoma
Michigan over Nebraska
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Pat McAfee:
Syracuse+17.5
South Carolina+10.5
FSU-45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Indiana over Illinois
Oklahoma over Auburn
Nebraska over Michigan
Florida State over Kent State
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Nick Saban:
Syracuse+17.5
Missouri-10.5
FSU-45.5
Miami (FL) over Florida
Illinois over Indiana
Missouri over South Carolina
Oklahoma over Auburn
Michigan over Nebraska
Florida State over Kent State
Utah over Texas Tech
TCU over SMU

Week 3 2025: CFB gambling picks are graded; results are in!

Week 3 of our 2025 college football season is in the books, and I forgot to post the gambling grades so they are coming late. Let’s jump right in.

Winners this week include Collin Wilson (14-7), Scott Van Pelt’s WINNERS (8-2), and Dave Portnoy/Clay Travis both of which went 9-3. However, this week’s big winner is none other than the impressive performance from Wes Reynolds at 24-14 against the spread. Congratulations Wes on a great winning week.

Super Dog picks went 4-2 on the week, with Kirk/Desmond/Stanford Steve and Pat all picking winners. Stanford Steve’s board went 1-2 on College Gameday. Josh Pate’s Ramen Noodle Express picks went 5-6 on the week.

In the money line picks, Chris “The Bear” Fallica booked the biggest profit with a net win of 5.3 units on 2 picks.

Everyone else is somewhere in the mix, so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

ATS results:

NamePctWinLossProfits
Wes_Reynolds_ATS63.1624147.67
Collin_Wilson_ATS66.671475.58
Scott_Van_Pelt_ATS80825.27
Dave_Portnoy_ATS75935.18
Clay_Travis_ATS75935.18
Doug_Kezirian_ATS85.71614.45
Andy_Staples_ATS83.33513.55
Kirk_Herbstreit_ATS100302.73
Pat_Forde_ATS80412.64
Mackenzie_Brooks_ATS75312.07
Kayce_Smith_ATS66.67421.64
Brandon_Walker_ATS66.67421.64
Adam_Kramer_ATS60641.45
Stuckey_ATS60641.41
Randy_Cross_ATS100100.91
Ross_Dellenger_ATS100100.91
Bryant_McFadden_ATS100100.91
Aaron_Taylor_ATS100100.91
Desmond_Howard_ATS66.67210.82
Nick_Saban_ATS66.67210.82
Pat_McAfee_ATS66.67210.82
Megan_Nunez_ATS66.67210.8
Geoff_Schwartz_ATS66.67210.82
Kelly_Stewart_ATS66.67210.82
Iain_MacMillan_ATS60320.73
Tom_Fornelli_ATS57.14430.64
Kyle_Hunter_ATS57.14430.64
Kenny_White_ATS57.14430.64
Bud_Elliott_ATS54.55650.45
Greg_McElroy_ATS5011-0.09
Matt_Youmans_ATS5022-0.26
Joe_Fortenbaugh_ATS5033-0.27
Pamela_Maldonado_ATS5033-0.27
Todd_Fuhrman_ATS5044-0.36
Rece_Davis_ATS001-1
Brian_Jones_ATS001-1
Anita_Marks_ATS001-1
Todd_McShay_ATS001-1
Rick_Neuheisel_ATS001-1
Ryen_Russillo_ATS001-1
Brett_McMurphy_ATS42.8634-1.27
Steve_Coughlin_ATS44.4445-1.27
Josh_Pate_ATS45.4556-1.45
Chip_Patterson_ATS45.4556-1.45
Emory_Hunt_ATS46.6778-1.68
Shehan_Jeyarajah_ATS47.37910-1.82
Chris_Fallica_ATS33.3324-2.18
JD_Pickell_ATS33.3324-2.18
Danny_Kanell_ATS41.6757-2.45
Joel_Klatt_ATS2014-3.09
Phil_Steele_ATS2014-3.09
Ari_Wasserman_ATS2014-3.09
Richard_Johnson_ATS42.11811-3.73
Dusty_Dvoracek_ATS14.2916-5.09
Rico_Bosco_ATS29.41512-7.45
Dan_Katz_ATS37.041017-7.91

Money line results:

NameROI.PctUnits.Up.DownN.Picks
Chris_Fallica_ML2655.32
Bud_Elliott_ML2204.42
Danny_Kanell_ML5024
Chip_Patterson_ML221.15
Megan_Nunez_ML95.240.951
Wes_Reynolds_ML66.670.671
Tom_Fornelli_ML-1.67-0.053
Kelly_Stewart_ML-11.67-0.353
Mackenzie_Brooks_ML-100-11
Emory_Hunt_ML-100-11
Ari_Wasserman_ML-100-11

Week 3 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Notre Dame-6.5 vs Texas A&M
Vanderbilt+3.5 vs South Carolina
Purdue vs Southern Cal over 59.5

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Arkansas+6.5 vs Ole Miss
Desmond Howard: Arkansas+6.5 vs Ole Miss
Stanford Steve: South Alabama+24.5 vs Auburn
Pat McAfee: Texas A&M+6.5 vs Notre Dame
Nick Saban: Washington State+5.5 vs North Texas
Rece Davis: Texas State+17.5 vs Arizona State

They picked a couple of games against the spread FYI.

Celebrity guest Candace Parker:
Alabama-20.5 vs Wisconsin
South Florida+17.5 vs Miami FL
South Carolina over Vanderbilt
Notre Dame over Texas A&M
LSU over Florida
Arkansas over Ole Miss
Miami (FL) over South Florida
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Tennessee over Georgia
Clemson over Georgia Tech
Alabama over Wisconsin

Kirk Herbstreit:
Alabama-20.5 vs Wisconsin
Miami FL-17.5 vs South Florida
Vanderbilt over South Carolina
Notre Dame over Texas A&M
LSU over Florida
Arkansas over Ole Miss
Miami (FL) over South Florida
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Clemson over Georgia Tech
Alabama over Wisconsin

Desmond Howard:
Wisconsin+20.5 vs Alabama
Miami FL-17.5 vs South Florida
South Carolina over Vanderbilt
Notre Dame over Texas A&M
LSU over Florida
Arkansas over Ole Miss
Miami (FL) over South Florida
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Georgia over Tennessee
Clemson over Georgia Tech
Alabama over Wisconsin

Pat McAfee:
Alabama-20.5 vs Wisconsin
South Florida+17.5 vs Miami FL
South Carolina over Vanderbilt
Texas A&M over Notre Dame
LSU over Florida
Ole Miss over Arkansas
West Virginia over Pittsburgh
Tennessee over Georgia
Georgia Tech over Clemson
Alabama over Wisconsin

Nick Saban:
Alabama-20.5 vs Wisconsin
Miami FL-17.5 vs South Florida
South Carolina over Vanderbilt
Notre Dame over Texas A&M
LSU over Florida
Ole Miss over Arkansas
Miami (FL) over South Florida
Pittsburgh over West Virginia
Georgia over Tennessee
Clemson over Georgia Tech
Alabama over Wisconsin