Our expert analysts have been on quite a roll the last few weeks. That is now over. We had a few big upsets this weekend, and because of that, our expert analysts collectively had a pretty rough week. Only two big winners this week. Desmond Howard went 6-1, including two FCS games they picked on Gameday. Tom Luginbill went 9-3 on the week including picking LSU and Okla St.
Losers this week include our celebrity guest picker Marcus Smart at 5-6. Other losers are Mel Kiper Jr. (2-3), Mark May (1-3), Brian Griese (1-2), Robert Smith (4-4). We had lots of mediocre performances from some big names this week. Lee Corso went 8-7 but nailed the upset with his headgear pick of Oklahoma St. Herbie went 8-7, Cowherd went 7-5, Dari Nowkhah went 6-5. No Pat Forde this week because he is too busy with Jameis Winston, college basketball, and swimming.
Upset specialist Todd McShay went 3-3, including going 1-1 on upset specials. Brad Edwards got his upset special and continues to roll in the second half of the season with Vandy over Tennessee this week. Mark Schlabach took the week off due to the fact that he seems to be in charge of the Jameis Winston reporting for ESPN. Upset Specialist Jennifer went 6-6 on the week and missed her pick of KState over OU.
Everyone else is somewhere in between. Check out the full slate below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.
Lee Corso: 8-7
RIGHT Iowa over Michigan
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
WRONG Lehigh over Lafayette
WRONG TAMU over LSU
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
WRONG Oregon over Arizona
RIGHT Mizzou over Ole Miss
RIGHT Mich St over NW
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
WRONG Penn St over Nebraska
RIGHT ND over BYU
WRONG Tennessee over Vandy
WRONG Oregon St over Washington
RIGHT KState over OU
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor (headgear pick)
Kirk Herbstreit: 8-7
RIGHT FSU over Idaho
RIGHT Miss st over Ark
RIGHT Vandy over Tenn
RIGHT UCF over Rutgers
WRONG Ucla over Ariz st
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
RIGHT Lafayette over Lehigh
WRONG TAMU over LSU
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
RIGHT Mich St over NW
WRONG Penn St over Nebraska
WRONG BYU over ND
WRONG Oregon St over Washington
WRONG KState over OU
Marcus Smart: 5-6
WRONG NW over Mich St
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
WRONG Penn St over Nebraska
RIGHT ND over BYU
WRONG TAMU over LSU
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
WRONG Tennessee over Vandy
RIGHT Ariz St over UCLA
WRONG Oregon St over Washington
RIGHT OU over KState
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
Desmond Howard: 6-1
RIGHT Nebraska over Penn St
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
RIGHT Lafayette over Lehigh
RIGHT LSU over TAMU
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
David Pollack: 0-1
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
Chris Fowler: 2-0
RIGHT Harvard over Yale
RIGHT Ariz st over ucla
Jennifer’s Picks: 6-6
WRONG TAMU over LSU
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
RIGHT Mich St over NW
RIGHT Clemson over Citadel
WRONG Penn St over Nebraska
RIGHT ND over BYU
RIGHT Mizzou over Ole Miss
RIGHT Vandy over Tennessee
WRONG Oregon St over Washington
WRONG KState over OU (upset special)
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
Chris Fallica: 0-1
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
Todd McShay: 3-3
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
WRONG TAMU over LSU
RIGHT Ariz St over UCLA
RIGHT Mizzou over Ole Miss
RIGHT Vandy over Tennessee (upset special)
WRONG Kansas over Iowa St (upset special #2)
Mel Kiper Jr.: 2-3
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
WRONG TAMU over LSU
RIGHT Mich St over NW
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
Dari Nowkhah: 6-5
RIGHT Ohio St over Indiana
RIGHT NIU over Toledo
RIGHT Duke over Wake Forest
WRONG BYU over Notre Dame
RIGHT Washington over Oregon St
RIGHT Mich St over NW
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
WRONG TAMU over LSU
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
Paul Finebaum: 3-0
RIGHT Mizzou over Ole Miss
RIGHT Fsu over Idaho
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
Colin Cowherd: 7-5
RIGHT Mich St over NW
WRONG KState over OU
RIGHT Ohio St over Indiana
WRONG Oregon over Arizona
RIGHT LSU over TAMU
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
WRONG BYU over ND
RIGHT Stanford over Cal
RIGHT Ariz St over UCLA
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
RIGHT USC over Colorado
Skip bayless: 1-1
WRONG Tamu over LSU
RIGHT Okla st over Baylor
Lou Holtz: 3-1
RIGHT Ariz St over UCLA
RIGHT LSU over TAMU
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
Mark May: 1-3
WRONG Tamu over LSU
WRONG Ucla over Ariz St
RIGHT Mizzou over ole miss
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
Brian Griese: 1-2
WRONG Tamu over LSU
RIGHT Ariz St over Ucla
WRONG Ole miss over mizzou
Mike Bellotti: 3-0
RIGHT Bama over Tenn-Chat
RIGHT FSU over Idaho
RIGHT Ohio St over Indiana
Robert Smith: 4-4
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
RIGHT Mizzou over Ole Miss
RIGHT Ariz St over UCLA
RIGHT LSU over Tamu
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
WRONG Oregon over Arizona
WRONG Kstate over OU
WRONG BYU over ND
Bill Plaschke: 1-0
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
Phil Steele: 3-0
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
RIGHT LSU over TAMU
RIGHT Mizzou over Ole Miss
Brad Edwards: 2-0
RIGHT FSU over Idaho
RIGHT Vandy over Tennessee (upset special)
Ryen Russillo: 0-1
WRONG Baylor over Okla St
Trevor Matich: 2-0
RIGHT Bama over Tenn-Chat
RIGHT Ohio St over Indiana
Matt Stinchcomb: 1-0
RIGHT Bama over Tenn-Chat
Tom Luginbill: 9-3
RIGHT Bama over Tenn-Chat
RIGHT NIU over Toledo
RIGHT Ohio St over Indiana
RIGHT FSU over Idaho
RIGHT Duke over Wake Forest
RIGHT Notre Dame over BYU
WRONG Oreg St over Washington
RIGHT Mich St over NW
WRONG UCLA over Ariz St
WRONG Ole Miss over Mizzou
RIGHT LSU over TAMU
RIGHT Okla St over Baylor
Danny Kanell: 1-0
RIGHT Duke over Wake Forest
Ivan Maisel: 1-0
RIGHT Mich St over NW
Jason Sehorn: 4-2
RIGHT Ariz st over ucla
RIGHT Mizzou over ole miss
RIGHT Wisconsin over Minnesota
WRONG Oregon over Arizona
RIGHT OU over Kstate
WRONG BYU over ND