Week 11 2016: #CFB Picks are graded; results are in!
Welcome back everyone. Week 11 of this college football season provided tremendous excitement and shocking upsets; upsets which will likely shake up very little due to 2, 3, and 4 still holding head-to-head over other top 10 tens. Anyways, these upsets provided some very mixed results from our panel of expert prognosticators so let’s jump right in.
Winners this week were few and far between. Winners included Stanford Steve (5-2 straight up, 5-3 ATS), Chris Doering (5-2), and not much else. @GamedayJen went 10-5 on the week continuing her hot streak, but she fell just short of our week 11 winners. This week’s winner blew out the competition. Our week 11 winner was none other than Phil Steele; a man due for a win in a big way. Phil went 18-7 straight up, but also went an astounding 20-6 against the spread. If you followed Phil’s public picks this week then you are probably looking for new residence on your own private island with your winnings. Congratulations Phil, you can expect this week’s congratulatory gift certificate to the Sizzler so I hope you enjoy it.
Losers this week were all over the place. Herbie McHerbstreit went 5-8 on the week. Marcus Spears went 3-4 on SEC Nation. Dusty Dvoracek went 2-1 straight up on the week, but somehow managed an 0-5 week against the spread. The Bear went 2-4 straight up and a solid 2-7 against the spread. Bruce Feldman went 5-6 straight up and 3-7-1 against the spread. Joseph Galloway went 3-4 on the week. Everyone’s favorite Danny Kanell went 2-4 straight up and 1-1 ATS. SVP’s Winners went 2-3 on the week. Since those are all pretty bad let’s just give it to Dusty Dvoracek, because an 0-5 week against the spread is pretty funny.
Lee Corso’s headgear pick missed on another one, going with Washington over USC. Special guest celebrity Joel McHale continued this season’s trend of showing up ill prepared, providing little-to-no contribution to the show, but managed a 7-4 record this week. I’m sure it is much harder than I realize to track down celebrities relevant to the home team, but could we not at least get someone who likes football to show up for this? I remember a time before special celebrity guests on College Gameday, and they got along just fine without Katy Perry throwing corndogs at the camera crew (even though that has become a classic moment). So make sure to write your congressman or Lee Fitting and let them know you demand change.
Anyways, everyone else is down below to check out the full slate of results to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality ended up!
Lee Corso: 7-5
WRONG Washington over USC (Headgear pick)
RIGHT Mich St over Rutgers
RIGHT Fordham over Holy Cross
RIGHT WVU over Texas
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
WRONG Arkansas over LSU
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
WRONG Indiana over Penn St
RIGHT Navy over Tulsa
WRONG Oregon over Stanford
Memphis+3.5 vs USF (Super Dog)
Kirk Herbstreit: 5-8
RIGHT OU over Baylor
WRONG Arkansas over LSU
WRONG Rutgers over Mich St
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
WRONG Vanderbilt over Mizzou
RIGHT Fordham over Holy Cross
WRONG Texas over WVU
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
WRONG Minnesota over Nebraska
WRONG Tulsa over Navy
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon
WRONG Washington over USC
Vanderbilt+3.5 vs Mizzou (Super Dog)
Desmond Howard: 8-6
RIGHT OU over Baylor
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
RIGHT AF over CSU
RIGHT Wash St over Cal
RIGHT Mich St over Rutgers
WRONG Indiana over Penn St
RIGHT Fordham over Holy Cross
WRONG Texas over WVU
WRONG Kentucky over Tennessee
WRONG Minnesota over Nebraska
RIGHT Navy over Tulsa
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon
WRONG Washington over USC
TTU+11.5 vs Ok St (Super Dog)
Joel McHale: 7-4
RIGHT Fordham over Holy Cross
WRONG Texas over WVU
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
WRONG Indiana over Penn St
RIGHT Navy over Tulsa
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon
WRONG Washington over USC
Jennifer’s Picks: 10-5
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
RIGHT Wash St over Cal
RIGHT Boise St over Hawaii
WRONG Clemson over Pitt
RIGHT Fordham over Holy Cross
WRONG Texas over WVU
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
RIGHT Nebraska over Minnesota
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
RIGHT Navy over Tulsa
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon
WRONG Washington over USC
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
Rece Davis:
Oregon St+11.5 vs UCLA (Super Dog)
David Pollack: 2-2
RIGHT WVU over Texas
WRONG Washington over USC
RIGHT OU over Baylor
WRONG Arkansas over LSU
Paul Finebaum: 4-3
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
WRONG Vanderbilt over Mizzou
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina
Tim Tebow: 4-3
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
WRONG Vanderbilt over Mizzou
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina
Marcus Spears: 3-4
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
WRONG Vanderbilt over Mizzou
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss
WRONG S.Carolina over Florida
Andrea Adelson: 4-3
WRONG UNC over Duke
RIGHT NC St over Syracuse
RIGHT FSU over BC
RIGHT Miami FL over UVA
WRONG Clemson over Pitt
WRONG VT over GT
RIGHT Louisville over Wake Forest
Charles Arbuckle: 9-9
RIGHT Ohio St over Maryland
RIGHT Louisville over Wake Forest
RIGHT Wisconsin over Illinois
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
RIGHT OU over Baylor
WRONG Washington over USC
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
WRONG Clemson over Pitt
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
WRONG VT over GT
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
RIGHT OK St over TTU
WRONG Texas over WVU
WRONG Minnesota over Nebraska
RIGHT Notre Dame over Army
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG Kansas over Iowa St
Stanford Steve Coughlin: 5-2 straight up, 5-3 ATS
WRONG Washington over USC 28-24
RIGHT Houston over Tulane 38-10
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon 26-23
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
WRONG Minnesota over Nebraska
RIGHT Georgia over Auburn
RIGHT USC+9 vs Washington
WRONG Houston-23 vs Tulane
RIGHT OU-15.5 vs Baylor
WRONG Oregon+3.5 vs Stanford
RIGHT Penn St-7 vs Indiana
WRONG Minnesota ML vs Nebraska
RIGHT Georgia ML vs Auburn
RIGHT Vanderbilt vs Mizzou under 52
Colin Cowherd: 1-1 straight up, 2-1 ATS
WRONG Washington over USC (by about 2 TD)
RIGHT ND over Army
RIGHT ND-14 vs Army
WRONG Washington-8 vs USC
RIGHT Iowa+21.5 vs Michigan
Chris Doering: 5-2
WRONG Vanderbilt over Mizzou 26-20
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentuckky
RIGHT Georgia over Auburn
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss
Dusty Dvoracek: 2-1 straight up, 0-5 ATS
RIGHT Ok St over TTU
RIGHT Wash St over Cal
WRONG Clemson over Pitt
WRONG Baylor+17 vs OU
WRONG OK St-13 vs TTU
WRONG Ariz St+6 vs Utah
WRONG Miss St+30 vs Alabama
WRONG Oregon+3 vs Stanford
Brad Edwards: 1-0 ATS
RIGHT Auburn vs Georgia under 50.5
Chris Fallica: 2-4 straight up, 2-7 ATS
WRONG Washington over USC 28-24
WRONG Oregon over Stanford 32-30
WRONG Ariz St over Utah
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
WRONG Georgia So over UL-Lafayette
RIGHT WKU over UNT
RIGHT Washington vs USC under 62.5
RIGHT UL-Lafayette+8.5 vs Georgia Southern
WRONG UNT+29 vs WKU
WRONG Oregon+3.5 vs Stanford (agreed w/ Stanford Steve)
WRONG Oregon+3 vs Stanford (Bear’s Bank)
WRONG Indiana+7 vs Penn St (Bear’s Bank)
WRONG Ariz St+6 vs Utah
WRONG Ariz St ML vs Utah
WRONG Hawaii+18 vs Boise St (Bear’s Bank)
Bruce Feldman: 5-6 straight up, 3-7-1 ATS
WRONG UNC over Duke
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
RIGHT ND over Army
WRONG Clemson over Pitt
WRONG Washington over USC
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG Minnesota over Nebraska
WRONG UNC-11 vs Duke
RIGHT OU-15.5 vs Baylor
WRONG Miss St+29 vs Alabama
WRONG Indiana+7 vs Penn St
WRONG Auburn-10 vs Georgia
RIGHT ND-13.5 vs Army
WRONG Clemson-20.5 vs Pitt
RIGHT USC+9 vs Washington
WRONG Michigan-21.5 vs Iowa
WRONG Arkansas+7 vs LSU
TIE Minnesota+7 vs Nebraska
Pat Forde: 0-1
WRONG Washington over USC (by 7)
Joey Galloway: 3-4
WRONG UNC over Duke
WRONG Washington over USC
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
WRONG Clemson over Pitt
Mike Golic: 0-2
WRONG Washington over USC
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
Danny Kanell: 2-4 straight up, 1-1 ATS
WRONG UNC over Duke
WRONG Washington over USC
RIGHT OU over Baylor
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina
WRONG Arkansas over LSU
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
WRONG Michigan-21.5 vs Iowa
RIGHT USC+8.5 vs Washington
Joel Klatt: 1-0
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
Matt Leinart: 0-1
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
Mark May: 0-2
WRONG Washington over USC 42-34
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
Greg McElroy: 1-0
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
Booger McFarland: 4-3
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky
WRONG Auburn over Georgia
WRONG Vanderbilt over Mizzou
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss
Ryen Russillo: 0-1 straight up, 1-1 ATS
WRONG Michigan over Iowa
WRONG Michigan-21.5 vs Iowa
RIGHT USC+8.5 vs Washington
Mark Schlabach: 1-1
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
WRONG Washington over USC
Robert Smith: 0-1
WRONG Washington over USC
Phil Steele: 18-7 straight up, 20-6 ATS
RIGHT NW over Purdue
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
WRONG Michigan over Iowa (by 17-21)
WRONG Clemson over Pitt (by 24+)
WRONG Washington over USC (by 10 or more, by 10-14 pts)
RIGHT UCLA over Oregon St
RIGHT Penn St over Indiana (by more than 7, by 10-14)
RIGHT Ohio St over Maryland
RIGHT Wisconsin over Illinois (by 28)
RIGHT Navy over Tulsa (upset)
WRONG VT over GT (by more than 2 td)
WRONG ECU over SMU by 7 (on the number)
RIGHT OK St over TTU (by 7)
WRONG TAMU over Ole Miss (by less than a TD, by 3-7 pts)
RIGHT Troy over App St
RIGHT LSU over Arkansas
RIGHT Florida over S.Carolina (by two TD)
RIGHT OU over Baylor (by 3 TD)
RIGHT ND over Army
RIGHT Colorado over Arizona (by 17 or more)
WRONG Texas over WVU
RIGHT Stanford over Oregon
RIGHT SDSU over Nevada
RIGHT Tennessee over Kentucky (by at least 2 TD)
RIGHT Louisville over Wake Forest (by 35)
RIGHT NW-13.5 vs Purdue
RIGHT Alabama-30 vs Miss St
RIGHT Iowa+24 vs Michigan
WRONG Clemson-12 vs Pitt
WRONG Washington-8 vs USC
RIGHT Penn St-7 vs Indiana
RIGHT Marshall+9.5 vs MTSU
RIGHT Ohio St-28.5 vs Maryland
RIGHT Wisconsin-26 vs Illinois
RIGHT Navy+1.5 vs Tulsa
WRONG VT-14 vs GT
RIGHT TTU+12.5 vs Ok St
RIGHT Ole Miss+10 vs TAMU
RIGHT Troy PK over App St
RIGHT Troy-1.5 vs App St
RIGHT LSU-7 vs Arkansas
RIGHT Florida-11.5 vs S.Carolina
RIGHT OU-16 vs Baylor
RIGHT OU-17.5 vs Baylor
RIGHT ND-13.5 vs Army
RIGHT Colorado-15.5 vs Arizona
WRONG Texas+2 vs WVU
RIGHT Stanford-3 vs Oregon
RIGHT SDSU-23.5 vs Nevada
WRONG Buffalo+10.5 vs Miami OH
WRONG Tennessee-13.5 vs Kentucky
Clint Stoerner: 1-0
RIGHT Alabama over Miss St
Scott Van Pelt’s WINNERS: 2-3 ATS
WRONG Ariz St+6 vs Utah
WRONG Indiana+7 vs Penn St
WRONG Maryland+29 vs Ohio St
RIGHT Iowa+21.5 vs Michigan
RIGHT USC+8.5 vs Washington
Dave Wannstedt: 0-1
WRONG Washington over USC
Dan Wetzel: 0-1 straight up, 0-1 ATS
Washington over USC
Washington-8.5 vs USC