Week 12 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dogs, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
BYU-3.5 vs TCU
Illinois-14.5 vs Maryland
Notre Dame vs Pitt over 54

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Baylor+9.5
Desmond Howard: Pitt+12.5
Stanford Steve: Tennessee Tech+22.5
Pat McAfee: WVU+10.5
Nick Saban: Navy+9.5
Rece Davis: Utah State+6.5

Celebrity guest Aaron Donald:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Southern Cal over Iowa
Virginia over Duke
Alabama over Oklahoma
Arizona State over West Virginia
Pittsburgh over Notre Dame
Navy over South Florida
Cincinnati over Arizona

Kirk Herbstreit:
TCU over BYU
Southern Cal over Iowa
Virginia over Duke
Oklahoma over Alabama
Arizona State over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Pittsburgh
South Florida over Navy
Arizona over Cincinnati

Desmond Howard:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Southern Cal over Iowa
Duke over Virginia
Alabama over Oklahoma
Arizona State over West Virginia
Pittsburgh over Notre Dame
South Florida over Navy
Cincinnati over Arizona

Pat McAfee:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Iowa over Southern Cal
Duke over Virginia
Oklahoma over Alabama
West Virginia over Arizona State
Notre Dame over Pittsburgh
Navy over South Florida
Cincinnati over Arizona

Nick Saban:
BYU over TCU
Georgia over Texas
Southern Cal over Iowa
Duke over Virginia
Alabama over Oklahoma
Arizona State over West Virginia
Notre Dame over Pittsburgh
South Florida over Navy
Cincinnati over Arizona

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 56-18 (75.68%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic

Week 11 2025: CFB gambling picks are graded; results are in!

Week 11 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our esteemed panel of gamblers are graded. We are running a day late this week, so I offer my apologies to everyone. I’ll blame the YoutubeTV/Disney dispute.

Winners this week include Bud Elliott (10-4) and Kenny White (6-1), but our undisputed winner this week is Stanford Steve at 7-1 this week. He went 2-1 on the board on College Gameday this week, and managed a 5-0 run on ESPN BET Live picking games. Congratulations to Stanford Steve on a great winning week.

Super Dog picks went 4-2 on College Gameday this week, with Desmond and Pat being the losers. Scott Van Pelt’s WINNERS went 3-2. Josh Pate’s Ramen Noodle Express went 7-4.

Tom Fornelli had an impressive winning week in the money line picks, with a profit 8.7 units across 6 picks. Congratulations to Tom Fornelli on a great winning week.

Everyone else is somewhere in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

ATS results:

NamePctWinLossTieProfits
Steve_Coughlin_ATS87.57105.36
Bud_Elliott_ATS71.4310405.09
Kenny_White_ATS85.716104.45
Joel_Klatt_ATS1004003.64
Pamela_Maldonado_ATS1004003.64
Brandon_Walker_ATS1004003.64
Dusty_Dvoracek_ATS707303.36
Chris_Fallica_ATS707303.34
Bruce_Feldman_ATS804102.64
Phil_Steele_ATS804102.64
Josh_Pate_ATS63.647402.36
Richard_Johnson_ATS58.8210712.09
Dan_Katz_ATS57.8911802
JD_Pickell_ATS66.674201.64
Adam_Kramer_ATS62.55301.55
Rico_Bosco_ATS57.148601.27
Wes_Reynolds_ATS5511920.93
Randy_Cross_ATS1001000.91
Rece_Davis_ATS1001000.91
Ross_Dellenger_ATS1001000.91
Jeff_Ma_ATS66.672100.82
Kelly_Stewart_ATS66.672100.82
Emory_Hunt_ATS53.85141200.64
Stewart_Mandel_ATS603200.73
Andy_Staples_ATS603210.73
Scott_Van_Pelt_ATS603200.73
Matt_Youmans_ATS57.144300.64
Tom_Fornelli_ATS55.565400.55
Stuckey_ATS53.857600.41
Rufus_Peabody_ATS50110-0.09
Scott_Spreitzer_ATS50220-0.18
Dave_Portnoy_ATS50330-0.27
Kayce_Smith_ATS50330-0.27
Clay_Travis_ATS50550-0.45
Mackenzie_Brooks_ATS0010-1
Brian_Jones_ATS0010-1
Anita_Marks_ATS0010-1
Rick_Neuheisel_ATS0010-1
Aaron_Taylor_ATS0010-1
Kirk_Herbstreit_ATS33.33120-1.09
Nick_Saban_ATS33.33120-1.09
Pat_McAfee_ATS33.33120-1.09
Geoff_Schwartz_ATS33.33120-1.09
Kyle_Hunter_ATS40230-1.18
Ralph_Russo_ATS40230-1.18
Ari_Wasserman_ATS40231-1.18
Joe_Fortenbaugh_ATS42.86340-1.27
Chip_Patterson_ATS45.45560-1.45
Celebrity_Guest_ATS0020-2
Desmond_Howard_ATS0030-3
Pat_Forde_ATS20140-3.09
Iain_MacMillan_ATS20140-3.09
Doug_Kezirian_ATS28.57250-3.18
Todd_Fuhrman_ATS25260-4.18
Collin_Wilson_ATS30370-4.27
Shehan_Jeyarajah_ATS35.71591-4.45
Danny_Kanell_ATS33.335100-5.45
Megan_Nunez_ATS0070-7

Money line results:

NameROI.PctUnits.Up.DownN.Picks
Tom_Fornelli_ML1458.76
Emory_Hunt_ML2314.622
Chris_Fallica_ML42.52.556
Chip_Patterson_ML57.52.34
Richard_Johnson_ML1851.851
Wes_Reynolds_ML75.711.512
Danny_Kanell_ML36.751.474
Collin_Wilson_ML1051.051
Kelly_Stewart_ML26.670.83
Brandon_Walker_ML-100-11
Bud_Elliott_ML-25.75-1.034

Week 11 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super dog picks, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Screenshot

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Mississippi State+9.5 vs Georgia
West Virginia-6.5 vs Colorado

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: UConn+8.5
Desmond Howard: BYU+11.5
Stanford Steve: Wake Forest+6.5
Pat McAfee: Arkansas St+4.5
Nick Saban: Stanford+7.5
Rece Davis: Hawaii+6.5

Celebrity guest Patrick Mahomes:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Virginia over Wake Forest
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

Kirk Herbstreit:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Wake Forest over Virginia
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Iowa over Oregon
Georgia over Mississippi State

Desmond Howard:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Virginia over Wake Forest
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

Pat McAfee:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Notre Dame-26.5 vs Navy
Alabama over LSU
Wake Forest over Virginia
Florida State over Clemson
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

Nick Saban:
Indiana-15.5 vs Penn State
Navy+26.5 vs Notre Dame
Alabama over LSU
Virginia over Wake Forest
Clemson over Florida State
Texas A&M over Missouri
Oregon over Iowa
Texas Tech over BYU
Georgia over Mississippi State

When Kirk Herbstreit, Desmond Howard, Pat McAfee, Nick Saban and the celebrity guest all make the same selection they are 53-18 (74.65%) all-time! #SavingTheGraphic