We have put the final nail in the coffin of our 2016-17 regular season with the completion of Army-Navy on Saturday. Before we unleash Bowl Mania picks (which will be an absolute BONANZA of picks), we need to take a look at the season standings below.
As always, we take the body of work provided by all of our expert pickers when our voting committee (of one) decides who wins on any given week or season. Our top competitors have been neck and neck all season long, and we are pleased to award @GamedayJen with her first ever regular season championship! She came in at 148-50 on the season for an average of 74.75%. She barely outnicked Phil Steele with a week 15 5-0 record picking Army-Navy and some fun FCS, D2 and D3 games against the Gameday crew. Phil Steele and Joey Galloway, along with Jen, were in a virtual 3-way tie the entire season at the top. Bowl Season is always where one can make or break a season, and where legends are made. Stay tuned throughout bowl season for a ton of picks to see how the season ends up!
| 2016-17 Season | Straight Up Record | Straight Up % | ATS | ATS % |
| Mike Bellotti | 2-0 | 100.00% | ||
| Brett McMurphy | 6-1 | 100.00% | ||
| Todd McShay | 1-0 | 100.00% | ||
| Mel Kiper Jr. | 8-1 | 88.89% | ||
| Brad Edwards | 5-1 | 83.33% | 3-3 | 50.00% |
| Mack Brown | 13-3 | 81.25% | ||
| Greg McElroy | 31-8 | 79.49% | ||
| Jordan Rodgers | 17-5 | 77.27% | ||
| Mark Schlabach | 16-5 | 76.19% | ||
| Clint Stoerner | 25-8 | 75.76% | ||
| Matt Stinchcomb | 9-3 | 75.00% | ||
| Jennifer’s Picks | 148-50 | 74.75% | ||
| Phil Steele | 229-78 | 74.59% | 162-146-7 | 52.54% |
| Joey Galloway | 54-19 | 73.97% | ||
| Andrea Adelson | 85-30 | 73.91% | ||
| Marcus Spears | 55-20 | 73.33% | ||
| Ryen Russillo | 16-6 | 72.73% | 18-22-2 | 45.24% |
| Paul Finebaum | 59-23 | 71.95% | ||
| Scott Van Pelt | 5-2 | 71.43% | 40-36-0 | 52.63% |
| Dusty Dvoracek | 33-37 | 70.69% | 33-37-2 | 47.22% |
| David Pollack | 40-17 | 70.18% | ||
| Pat Forde | 175-75 | 70.00% | 18-22-1 | 45.12% |
| Dari Nowkhah | 27-12 | 69.23% | 5-8-2001 | 39.29% |
| Charles Arbuckle | 105-47 | 69.08% | ||
| Dan Wetzel | 15-7 | 68.18% | 10-13 | 43.48% |
| Lee Corso | 109-51 | 68.13% | ||
| Bruce Feldman | 102-48 | 68.00% | 68-78 | 46.67% |
| Joel Klatt | 19-9 | 67.86% | ||
| Tim Tebow | 48-23 | 67.61% | ||
| Kirk Herbstreit | 108-52 | 67.50% | ||
| Booger McFarland | 57-28 | 67.06% | ||
| Robert Smith | 10-5 | 66.67% | ||
| Trevor Matich | 14-7 | 66.67% | ||
| Danny Kanell | 46-23 | 66.67% | 19-26-2 | 42.55% |
| Colin Cowherd | 16-8 | 66.67% | ||
| Desmond Howard | 112-61 | 64.74% | ||
| Stanford Steve Coughlin | 55-30 | 64.71% | 51-48-4 | 51.46% |
| Celebrity Guests Overall | 102-56 | 64.56% | ||
| Chris Doering | 44-26 | 62.86% | ||
| Chris Fallica | 59-39 | 60.20% | 65-58-4 | 52.76% |
| Dave Wannstedt | 10-7 | 58.82% | ||
| Jason Seorn | 4-3 | 57.14% | ||
| Rece Davis | 11-17 | 39.29% | ||
| Rufus Peabody | 33.33% | |||
| Season Totals | 2113-931 | 69.42% | 493-499-30 | 49.71% |