Week 13 2025: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 13 is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded. Let’s jump right in.

Celebrity guest picker Marcus Mariota had a rough week picking games on College Gameday with a 3-6 record. Kirk Herbstreit and Desmond Howard both went 4-5 picking games on the show. Pat McAfee matched Marcus Mariota at 3-6, which means our big winner on College Gameday was Nick Saban at 5-4.

Everyone else is in the mix, so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

NamePctWinLoss
David_Hale10090
Dusty_Dvoracek10060
Paul_Finebaum10040
Josh_Pate10040
Jordan_Rodgers10040
Tim_Tebow10040
JD_Pickell10030
Phil_Steele10030
Chris_Fallica10020
Tom_Fornelli90.48192
Rick_Neuheisel9091
Danny_Kanell88.8981
Chip_Patterson85173
Shehan_Jeyarajah84.21163
Rece_Davis83.3351
Greg_McElroy83.3351
David_Pollack83.3351
Pete_Thamel83.3351
Richard_Johnson82.35143
Andrea_Adelson77.7872
Aaron_Taylor77.7872
Steve_Coughlin7531
Roman_Harper7531
Joel_Klatt7531
Andy_Staples71.4352
Brian_Jones7073
Randy_Cross66.6763
Jimbo_Fisher66.6721
Pat_Forde66.6721
Eric_Mac_Lain66.6721
Ralph_Russo66.6721
Stewart_Mandel6032
Nick_Saban55.5654
Jennifer55.5654
Bruce_Feldman5022
Kirk_Herbstreit44.4445
Desmond_Howard44.4445
Pat_McAfee33.3336
Celebrity_Guest33.3336
Average75.8622070