2021-22 Season: Full season grades are finalized! Results are in!

The 2021-22 season is in the books and the picks have been graded. It is now time to crown our yearly champions.  We will be crowning two champions again this year; one champion being analysts picking games straight up and the other champion being our gambling champion. Our analyst champion will be graded on our experimental GDC grading system for the first time ever.

Without further adieu, I present to you our analyst champion for the 2021-22 season: Dennis Dodd from CBS Sports went 226-81 straight up for a percentage of 73.62% with a GDC value of 127.083! Runners up were Tom Fornelli (111.37 GDC) and Chip Patterson (100.883 GDC). That’s an all CBS Sports podium for the first time ever.

Our gambling champion for the 2021-22 season is Bud Elliott of 247 and Cover 3 podcast fame. He went 272-198-9 on the season for a win percentage of 57.87%! Several others had a higher win rate, but assuming -110 lines on average Bud Elliott absolutely crushed the competition for 49.28 units of profit this season.

Honorable mention goes to Kelly Stewart for winning our money line picks this year. She was up 25.14 units over 41 picks on the year.

Congratulations to all competitors. I hope you’ll all be back next season

Analyst grades:

NamePctWinLossGDC.Value
Average64.4933731857NA
Dennis.Dodd73.6222681127.083
Tom.Fornelli70.1922696111.37
Chip.Patterson68.55218100100.883
Brady.Quinn75.571334379.736
Jennifer63.961428054.307
David.Hale66.491256354.097
Lee.Corso64.521206648.671
Danny.Kanell69.34954245.857
Andrea.Adelson70.43813441.533
Pat.Forde59.315310541.386
Pete.Thamel74.44672340.607
Desmond.Howard60.781248037.962
Mark.May66.67743733.202
Celebrity.Guest59.771047030.655
Jon.Berger75481628.377
Stewart.Mandel59.171006927.603
Joey.Galloway67.42602926.949
Aaron.Taylor62.96684025.757
Brian.Jones60.94785025.614
Steve.Coughlin68.92512325.035
Dan.Wetzel64.44583222.24
Lou.Holtz61.26684321.588
Bruce.Feldman58.99825720.846
Phil.Steele68.97401818.956
Chris.Fallica64.18432416.121
Colin.Cowherd77.4224716.058
Mark.Richt62.03493015.921
Paul.Finebaum70.73291215.062
Eric.Mac.Lain59.14553813.853
Rick.Neuheisel55.64745912.508
Scott.Van.Pelt84.2116312.282
Chris.Doering76.9220612.103
Kevin.Carter65.85271411.43
Roman.Harper64.29271510.587
Jordan.Rodgers66.67221110.094
Kirk.Herbstreit53.899859.325
Reggie.Bush77.781449.251
Tim.Tebow63.4126159.212
Corso.Headgear73.681458.49
Bob.Stoops751247.59
Randy.Cross53.5468597.326
Houston.Nutt63.3319117.115
Brett.McMurphy59.0926186.33
Dusty.Dvoracek66.671475.894
David.Pollack57.5819144.442
EJ.Manuel52.4443391.845
Adam.Rittenberg48.651819-1.486
Matt.Leinart47.621011-1.493
Greg.McElroy49.092728-2.834

Grambling grades:

NamePctWinLossTieProfit
Bud.Elliott.ATS57.87272198949.28
Kelly.Stewart.ATS64.296335122.27
Scott.Van.Pelt.ATS62.266640120
Colin.Cowherd.ATS69.773013114.27
Pete.Thamel.ATS58.277453414.27
Tom.Fornelli.ATS57.348261513.55
Norm.Hitzges.ATS56.179171111.73
David.Hale.ATS55.2610585210.46
Brandon.Walker.ATS55.29947619.46
Brady.Quinn.ATS53.2624521547.73
Pamela.Maldonado.ATS54.6957937.36
Steve.Coughlin.ATS56.41443416
Danny.Kanell.ATS53.0621719255.27
Jon.Berger.ATS54.01746334.27
Desmond.Howard.ATS69.239404.18
Matt.Youmans.ATS55.26423444.18
Lee.Corso.ATS66.678413.27
Kirk.Herbstreit.ATS66.678413.27
Greg.McElroy.ATS56.41221703
Bill.Connelly.ATS54.17393312.45
Rece.Davis.ATS61.548502.27
Wes.Reynolds.ATS53.95413502.27
Tony.Barnhart.ATS53.57453901.91
Bryant.McFadden.ATS53.73363121.73
Erin.Kate.Dolan.ATS66.674201.64
Tyler.Fulghum.ATS54.29191601.27
Tim.Doyle.ATS5511901
Jeff.Ma.ATS66.672100.82
David.Pollack.ATS53.857600.36
Pat.Forde.ATS52.3467614-0.09
Trevor.Matich.ATS50220-0.18
Mark.May.ATS52.2957522-0.18
Anita.Marks.ATS50330-0.27
Scott.Spreitzer.ATS52.0825230-0.27
Bruce.Feldman.ATS52.2470644-0.36
Minty.Bets.ATS50880-0.73
Emory.Hunt.ATS52.1286791-0.82
Dan.Wetzel.ATS51.9766615-1
Rufus.Peabody.ATS5019191-1.73
Phil.Steele.ATS51.3557540-2.18
Kenny.White.ATS5024240-2.18
Megan.Makin.Money.ATS5151493-2.64
Chris.Doering.ATS48.7219200-2.73
Clay.Travis.ATS51.5285801-2.73
Dusty.Dvoracek.ATS45.9517201-4.55
Blaine.Brown.ATS47.5429323-5.64
Chris.Fallica.ATS5064642-5.82
Kayce.Smith.ATS46.6728320-6.55
Matt.Barrie.ATS37.59150-6.82
Stewart.Mandel.ATS49.6980816-8.27
Dave.Portnoy.ATS50.751351319-8.27
Joey.Galloway.ATS48.7860633-8.45
Todd.Fuhrman.ATS49.3374763-8.73
Joe.Fortenbaugh.ATS47.5749542-9.45
Doug.Kezirian.ATS45.3334412-10.09
Chip.Patterson.ATS47.3362697-12.64
Brett.McMurphy.ATS44.2142534-14.82
Rico.Bosco.ATS48.611051115-15.54
Adam.Kramer.ATS47.0672813-15.54
Katie.Pondiscio.ATS45.769824-19.27
Barrett.Sallee.ATS47.391451613-29.18
Dennis.Dodd.ATS47.021421603-30.91
Dan.Katz.ATS48.582562719-38.27

Money line results:

NameROI.PctUnits.Up.DownN.Picks
Kelly.Stewart.ML61.3225.1441
Pamela.Maldonado.ML20.1610.6853
Chip.Patterson.ML20.258.9144
Tom.Fornelli.ML7.983.9950
Bud.Elliott.ML7.213.0342
Tyler.Fulghum.ML62.52.54
Rico.Bosco.ML1951.951
Megan.ML23.291.637
Anita.Marks.ML1451.451
Dave.Portnoy.ML1201.21
Chris.Fallica.ML0.960.773
Kayce.Smith.ML100.22
Emory.Hunt.ML-18.33-0.553
Doug.Kezirian.ML-23.75-0.954
Phil.Steele.ML-100-11
Bryant.McFadden.ML-31.25-1.254
Tim.Doyle.ML-32.5-1.34
Bruce.Feldman.ML-100-22
Katie.Pondiscio.ML-100-22
Joe.Fortenbaugh.ML-43.75-3.58
Todd.Fuhrman.ML-37.81-4.1611
Jon.Berger.ML-40.75-6.9317
Brandon.Walker.ML-50.57-7.0814
Danny.Kanell.ML-14.22-7.1150

2019-20 Season: Final season grades are complete; results are in!

It is now time to crown our yearly champions.  We will be crowning two champions again this year.  Our first champion is picking games straight up and our second champion is for picking games against the spread.  Obviously not everyone below qualifies to be champion if they didn’t pick enough games.  My general rule is a minimum 100 games picked to be on the ballot.  Once we have all the finalists selected, our panel of voters decides our champions.  As always, our panel of voters consists of myself, a glass of bourbon, a box of Cheezits, and our cat Charley.

Without further adieu, I present to you our 2019-20 season results and yearly champions.  Our champion picking games straight up, coming in at 71.96% over 271 games is none other than noted football expert and my wife, @GamedayJen!  Our ATS champion, coming in at 58.78% over 131 games picked, is none other than the big time football reporter Pete Thamel!  Congratulations to you both, and look for a congratulatory basket of assorted bourbon and Cheezits which is being shipped to you as we speak!

Thank you all for tuning in for another season of football picks, and we will see you next season.

Straight up results:

percent n.correct n.wrong n.games
Kevin.Blackistone 100 1 0 1
Mike.Golic 100 3 0 3
Jackie.MacMullan 100 1 0 1
Booger.McFarland 100 2 0 2
Ryan.McGee 100 6 0 6
Brent.Musburger 100 1 0 1
Aaron.Murray 100 2 0 2
Petros.Papadakis 100 1 0 1
Jordan.Rodgers 100 7 0 7
Ryen.Russillo 100 1 0 1
Matt.Stinchcomb 100 2 0 2
Clint.Stoerner 100 1 0 1
Reggie.Bush 88.89 32 4 36
Urban.Meyer 86.49 32 5 37
Scott.Van.Pelt 84.62 11 2 13
Skip.Bayless 83.33 5 1 6
Jonathan.Vilma 81.25 13 3 16
Tim.Tebow 79.25 42 11 53
Todd.McShay 78.57 11 3 14
Tim.Cowlishaw 78.12 25 7 32
Dan.Wetzel 77.91 67 19 86
Jake.Trotter 77.78 7 2 9
Marcus.Spears 76.47 39 12 51
Matt.Leinart 76.32 29 9 38
Pete.Thamel 75.82 69 22 91
Chris.Fallica 75.71 53 17 70
Adam.Rittenberg 74.55 41 14 55
Paul.Finebaum 73.49 61 22 83
EJ.Manuel 73.24 52 19 71
Joel.Klatt 72.73 16 6 22
Joey.Galloway 72.22 39 15 54
Jennifer 71.96 195 76 271
Lou.Holtz 71.95 59 23 82
David.Pollack 71.82 79 31 110
Bruce.Feldman 71.72 142 56 198
Emmanuel.Acho 71.43 10 4 14
Mark.Richt 71.43 50 20 70
Chris.Doering 70.77 46 19 65
Lee.Corso 70.59 156 65 221
Danny.Kanell 70.27 52 22 74
Corso.Headgear 70 14 6 20
Steve.Coughlin 69.52 73 32 105
Pat.Forde 69.38 111 49 160
Andrea.Adelson 69.23 81 36 117
Phil.Steele 69.18 110 49 159
Gene.Chizik 69.09 38 17 55
Dusty.Dvoracek 69.09 38 17 55
Brett.McMurphy 68.75 22 10 32
Desmond.Howard 68.67 160 73 233
Colin.Cowherd 68.29 28 13 41
Jesse.Palmer 67.92 36 17 53
Kevin.Carter 67.5 27 13 40
Stewart.Mandel 67.48 139 67 206
Mark.May 67.07 55 27 82
Heather.Dinich 66.67 10 5 15
Dave.Wannstedt 66.67 2 1 3
Houston.Nutt 65.38 34 18 52
Aaron.Taylor 64.86 96 52 148
Kirk.Herbstreit 63.43 137 79 216
Brady.Quinn 62.5 25 15 40
Mark.Schlabach 62.5 10 6 16
Eric.Mac.Lain 61.97 44 27 71
Celebrity.Guest 61.11 121 77 198
Chris.Low 60 9 6 15
Rick.Neuheisel 58.74 84 59 143
Brian.Jones 57.69 90 66 156
Trevor.Matich 57.14 4 3 7
Randy.Cross 55.17 80 65 145
Greg.McElroy 55 22 18 40
Brad.Edwards 50 2 2 4
Mike.Greenberg 50 1 1 2
Jim.Mora.Jr 50 4 4 8
Dan.Orlovsky 50 1 1 2
Dari.Nowkhah 40 2 3 5
Ivan.Maisel 36.36 4 7 11
Rece.Davis 33.33 2 4 6
Stephen.A.Smith 33.33 1 2 3
Charles.Woodson 25 1 3 4
Charles.Arbuckle 0 0 1 1
Rod.Gilmore 0 0 1 1
Tom.Luginbill 0 0 1 1
Trey.Wingo 0 0 1 1

ATS Results:

percent n.correct n.wrong n.tie n.games
Joey.Galloway.ATS 77.42 24 7 0 31
Jake.Trotter.ATS 61.54 8 5 0 13
Bill.Connelly.ATS 60.66 36 23 2 61
Pete.Thamel.ATS 58.78 76 53 2 131
Tim.Cowlishaw.ATS 58.47 34 24 1 59
Lee.Corso.ATS 57.14 8 6 0 14
Doug.Kezirian.ATS 56.63 47 36 0 83
Dan.Wetzel.ATS 54.58 71 59 1 131
Jeff.Ma.ATS 54.55 12 10 0 22
Jesse.Palmer.ATS 54.41 18 15 1 34
Preston.Johnson.ATS 53.81 56 48 1 105
Steve.Coughlin.ATS 53.21 40 35 3 78
Joe.Fortenbaugh.ATS 52.42 32 29 1 62
Bruce.Feldman.ATS 52.3 101 92 3 196
Dusty.Dvoracek.ATS 51.1 45 43 3 91
Matt.Youmans.ATS 50.75 66 64 3 133
Clay.Travis.ATS 50.28 89 88 3 180
Jim.Donnan.ATS 50 7 7 0 14
Scott.Spreitzer.ATS 50 19 19 0 38
Norm.Hitzges.ATS 49.79 117 118 2 237
Phil.Steele.ATS 49.5 96 98 5 199
Todd.Fuhrman.ATS 49.28 67 69 3 139
Dan.Katz.ATS 49.04 125 130 5 260
Rufus.Peabody.ATS 48.39 29 31 2 62
Chris.Fallica.ATS 48.05 60 65 3 128
Dave.Portnoy.ATS 48.02 120 130 3 253
Stewart.Mandel.ATS 47.8 96 105 4 205
Pat.Forde.ATS 47.79 64 70 2 136
Rico.Bosco.ATS 47.44 54 60 3 117
Brett.McMurphy.ATS 46.36 25 29 1 55
Danny.Kanell.ATS 44.25 37 47 3 87
Scott.Van.Pelt.ATS 43.56 44 57 0 101
Kirk.Herbstreit.ATS 42.86 6 8 0 14
Desmond.Howard.ATS 42.86 6 8 0 14
Colin.Cowherd.ATS 42.39 19 26 1 46
FPI.ATS 40.91 18 26 0 44
Rece.Davis.ATS 39.29 5 8 1 14
Adam.Kramer.ATS 35 3 6 1 10
Brad.Edwards.ATS 33.33 2 4 0 6
Dari.Nowkhah.ATS 0 0 1 0 1