Week 15/16 2025 Season: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

We did a combination of week 15 and week 16 because the most recent episode of Gameday combined week 15 with Army/Navy. The picks are graded so let’s jump right in.

Celebrity guest picker Ernie Johnson went 4-2 across both weeks. Kirk Herbstreit went 3-2. Desmond Howard went 4-2. Nick Saban went 3-3. However, Pat McAfee managed to go 6-0 across weeks 15 and 16 for the biggest win.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

Week 15:

NamePctWinLoss
Pat_McAfee10050
Phil_Steele10020
Danny_Kanell10010
Jennifer8041
Bruce_Feldman77.7872
Brian_Jones77.7872
Rece_Davis71.4352
Aaron_Taylor66.6763
Josh_Pate66.6721
Greg_McElroy62.553
Desmond_Howard6032
Celebrity_Guest6032
Andy_Staples6032
Pete_Thamel57.1443
Dan_Wetzel57.1443
Randy_Cross55.5654
Shehan_Jeyarajah55.5654
Richard_Johnson55.5654
Stewart_Mandel55.5654
Rick_Neuheisel55.5654
Chip_Patterson55.5654
Dusty_Dvoracek5033
Kirk_Herbstreit5022
Joel_Klatt5022
JD_Pickell5022
Colin_Cowherd5011
Tom_Fornelli44.4445
Ralph_Russo44.4445
Nick_Saban4023
David_Pollack37.535
Pat_Forde33.3312
Chris_Fallica001
Mark_Ingram001
Matt_Leinart001
Urban_Meyer001
Brady_Quinn001
Average57.511585

Week 16 (Army/Navy):

NamePctWinLoss
Kirk_Herbstreit10010
Desmond_Howard10010
Nick_Saban10010
Pat_McAfee10010
Jennifer10010
Celebrity_Guest10010
Randy_Cross10010
Shehan_Jeyarajah10010
Brian_Jones10010
Chip_Patterson10010
Tom_Fornelli001
Richard_Johnson001
Rick_Neuheisel001
Aaron_Taylor001
Average71.43104

Week 14 2025: CFB gambling picks are graded; results are in!

Week 14 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our esteemed panel of gamblers are graded.

Winners this week include Emory Hunt (14-9) and Ari Wasserman (6-3), however our biggest winner was Bud Elliott, Esq. at 10-3. Congratulations to Bud on a great winning week.

Super Dog picks went 3-3 with Kirk, Desmond and Saban booking winners. Stanford Steve had a 3-0 week on the board on College Gameday. Josh Pate’s Ramen Noodle Express went 7-5. SVP took the week off, so there were no WINNERS to report on.

Emory Hunt was our only winner in the money line picks this week, so congratulations to Emory on a great winning week both against the spread and money line.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

ATS results:

NamePctWinLossTieProfits
Bud_Elliott_ATS76.9210306.09
Emory_Hunt_ATS60.8714903.73
Ari_Wasserman_ATS66.676302.45
Shehan_Jeyarajah_ATS57.8911802
Richard_Johnson_ATS57.8911802
Steve_Coughlin_ATS753101.73
Chip_Patterson_ATS606401.45
Josh_Pate_ATS58.337501.36
Collin_Wilson_ATS57.148601.23
Kirk_Herbstreit_ATS1001000.91
Desmond_Howard_ATS1001000.91
Nick_Saban_ATS1001000.91
Bruce_Feldman_ATS603200.73
Phil_Steele_ATS603200.73
Kenny_White_ATS57.144300.64
Rico_Bosco_ATS52.949800.18
Mackenzie_Brooks_ATS50110-0.09
Geoff_Schwartz_ATS50110-0.09
Scott_Spreitzer_ATS50110-0.09
Joel_Klatt_ATS50330-0.27
Kayce_Smith_ATS50330-0.27
Matt_Youmans_ATS50440-0.38
Danny_Kanell_ATS5010100-0.91
Rece_Davis_ATS0010-1
Ross_Dellenger_ATS0010-1
Pat_McAfee_ATS0010-1
Bryant_McFadden_ATS0010-1
Jeff_Ma_ATS33.33120-1.09
Rufus_Peabody_ATS33.33120-1.12
Kelly_Stewart_ATS33.33120-1.09
Pamela_Maldonado_ATS40230-1.18
Stewart_Mandel_ATS40230-1.18
Ralph_Russo_ATS40230-1.18
Brandon_Walker_ATS40230-1.18
JD_Pickell_ATS42.86340-1.27
Wes_Reynolds_ATS48.4816172-2.62
Dan_Katz_ATS45.8311130-3
Pat_Forde_ATS20140-3.09
Todd_Fuhrman_ATS20140-3.09
Iain_MacMillan_ATS20140-3.09
Chris_Fallica_ATS33.33360-3.29
Tom_Fornelli_ATS33.33360-3.27
Andy_Staples_ATS33.33360-3.27
Kyle_Hunter_ATS14.29160-5.09
Stuckey_ATS27.27381-5.27
Clay_Travis_ATS29.415120-7.45
Dave_Portnoy_ATS31.586130-7.55

Money line results:

NameROI.PctUnits.Up.DownN.Picks
Emory_Hunt_ML1341.341
Collin_Wilson_ML-8.33-0.172
Stuckey_ML-100-11
Brandon_Walker_ML-100-11
Wes_Reynolds_ML-40-1.23
Bud_Elliott_ML-100-33
Chip_Patterson_ML-100-33
Kelly_Stewart_ML-100-33
Chris_Fallica_ML-100-44
Danny_Kanell_ML-100-55
Tom_Fornelli_ML-44.17-5.312

Week 14 2025: CFB analyst picks are graded; results are in!

Week 14 of our 2025 college football season is in the books and the picks from our analysts are graded.

Celebrity guest picker Aidan Hutchinson went 6-3 on College Gameday. Nick Saban came out on top at 7-2. Desmond Howard went 6-3. Kirk Herbstreit went 5-3. Pat McAfee brought up the rear at 5-4.

Everyone else is in the mix so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week!

NamePctWinLoss
Dan_Wetzel10060
Steve_Coughlin10030
Jimbo_Fisher10030
Pat_Forde10020
Phil_Steele10020
Mark_Ingram10010
Matt_Leinart10010
Urban_Meyer10010
Brady_Quinn10010
Chip_Patterson95191
Greg_McElroy9091
Josh_Pate88.8981
Tom_Fornelli85.71183
Rece_Davis83.3351
JD_Pickell83.3351
David_Hale81.8292
David_Pollack81.8292
Roman_Harper8041
Andy_Staples8041
Tim_Tebow8041
Richard_Johnson78.95154
Nick_Saban77.7872
Jordan_Rodgers7531
Shehan_Jeyarajah73.68145
Andrea_Adelson72.7383
Desmond_Howard66.6763
Celebrity_Guest66.6763
Joel_Klatt66.6742
Bruce_Feldman66.6721
Eric_Mac_Lain66.6721
Kirk_Herbstreit62.553
Danny_Kanell62.553
Paul_Finebaum6032
Pat_McAfee55.5654
Jennifer55.5654
Ralph_Russo4023
Stewart_Mandel33.3312
Ross_Dellenger001
Chris_Fallica001
Average76.6720763