Week 10 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dogs, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
California+6.5 vs Virginia
Vanderbilt+3.5 vs Texas
Cincinnati+10.5 vs Utah

Screenshot

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: NC State+5.5
Desmond Howard: Cincinnati+10.5
Stanford Steve: Kansas State+7.5
Pat McAfee: Navy+6.5
Nick Saban: SMU+9.5
Rece Davis: California+5.5

Celebrity guest Alex Smith:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Oklahoma over Tennessee
Nebraska over Southern Cal
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Texas over Vanderbilt
Navy over North Texas
Air Force over Army

Kirk Herbstreit:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Cincinnati over Utah
Nebraska over Southern Cal
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Vanderbilt over Texas
Navy over North Texas
Army over Air Force

Desmond Howard:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Tennessee over Oklahoma
Southern Cal over Nebraska
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Vanderbilt over Texas
Navy over North Texas
Air Force over Army

Pat McAfee:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Oklahoma over Tennessee
Nebraska over Southern Cal
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Vanderbilt over Texas
Navy over North Texas
Army over Air Force

Nick Saban:
Ohio State-18.5 vs Penn St
Utah over Cincinnati
Tennessee over Oklahoma
Southern Cal over Nebraska
Texas Tech over Kansas State
Georgia over Florida
Texas over Vanderbilt
Navy over North Texas
Air Force over Army

Week 9 2025: CFB gambling picks are graded; results are in!

Week 9 of our college football season is in the books and the picks from our esteemed panel of gamblers are graded.

Winners this week include Wes Reynolds, Dan “Big Cat” Katz, Kayce Smith and Stanford Steve. However, this week’s biggest winner was Dave Portnoy at 8-3 against the number. Congratulations to Dave Portnoy on a great winning week.

Richard Johnson was our only winner of note in the money line picks this week with a profit of 2.28 units on one pick.

Super Dog picks went 3-2 on College Gameday this week. Kirk, Desmond and Stanford Steve booked winners while Saban and Rece Davis had losers. Pat McAfee’s pick was mysteriously skipped over so I look forward to seeing if they address this on Gameday next week. Stanford Steve went 2-1 on the board on College Gameday this week. Josh Pate’s Ramen Noodle Express went 6-5. Scott Van Pelt’s pseudo-WINNERS which he wrote on a whiteboard and posted to Twitter went 1-5.

Everyone else is in the mix, so check out the full slate of results below to see how your favorite (or most hated) personality did this week.

ATS results:

NamePctWinLossTieProfits
Dave_Portnoy_ATS72.738304.27
Wes_Reynolds_ATS58.82201414.03
Dan_Katz_ATS60151003.64
Kayce_Smith_ATS83.335103.55
Steve_Coughlin_ATS756203.45
Shehan_Jeyarajah_ATS61.1111713
Joel_Klatt_ATS804102.64
Andy_Staples_ATS71.435202.55
Bud_Elliott_ATS63.647402.36
Kelly_Stewart_ATS1002011.82
Joe_Fortenbaugh_ATS753101.73
Pamela_Maldonado_ATS66.674201.64
Rico_Bosco_ATS56.259701.18
Celebrity_Guest_ATS1001000.91
Randy_Cross_ATS1001000.91
Pat_McAfee_ATS1001000.91
Jeff_Ma_ATS66.672100.82
Rufus_Peabody_ATS66.672100.82
Geoff_Schwartz_ATS66.672100.82
Pat_Forde_ATS603200.73
Iain_MacMillan_ATS603200.73
Phil_Steele_ATS603200.73
Tom_Fornelli_ATS55.565400.55
Josh_Pate_ATS54.556500.45
Clay_Travis_ATS53.857600.36
Ross_Dellenger_ATS500010
Brian_Jones_ATS500010
Kirk_Herbstreit_ATS50110-0.09
Desmond_Howard_ATS50110-0.09
Nick_Saban_ATS50110-0.09
Greg_McElroy_ATS50220-0.18
Ari_Wasserman_ATS50330-0.27
Chris_Fallica_ATS50441-0.36
Danny_Kanell_ATS50660-0.55
Collin_Wilson_ATS50990-0.84
Rece_Davis_ATS0010-1
Rick_Neuheisel_ATS0010-1
Aaron_Taylor_ATS0010-1
Scott_Spreitzer_ATS40230-1.18
Doug_Kezirian_ATS42.86340-1.27
Stuckey_ATS46.15670-1.37
Todd_Fuhrman_ATS25130-2.09
Megan_Nunez_ATS33.33241-2.18
JD_Pickell_ATS33.33240-2.18
Brandon_Walker_ATS33.33240-2.18
Matt_Youmans_ATS37.5351-2.26
Mackenzie_Brooks_ATS41.67570-2.45
Kyle_Hunter_ATS28.57250-3.18
Adam_Kramer_ATS33.33360-3.27
Brett_McMurphy_ATS16.67151-4.09
Scott_Van_Pelt_ATS16.67150-4.09
Dusty_Dvoracek_ATS30370-4.27
Chip_Patterson_ATS30370-4.27
Kenny_White_ATS14.29160-5.09
Richard_Johnson_ATS33.337141-7.64
Emory_Hunt_ATS37.512200-9.19

Money line results:

NameROI.PctUnits.Up.DownN.Picks
Richard_Johnson_ML2282.281
Collin_Wilson_ML86.960.871
Kelly_Stewart_ML13.330.43
Danny_Kanell_ML7.50.34
Chip_Patterson_ML-20-0.63
Mackenzie_Brooks_ML-100-11
Matt_Youmans_ML-100-11
Wes_Reynolds_ML-44.44-1.333
Chris_Fallica_ML-40-1.64
Emory_Hunt_ML-100-33
Tom_Fornelli_ML-61.67-3.76
Bud_Elliott_ML-100-44

Week 9 2025: Saturday morning College Gameday picks! Super Dogs, Stanford Steve’s board, celebrity guests and more!

Stanford Steve’s Board:
Minnesota+8.5 vs Iowa
Miami OH-2 vs Western Michigan
Vanderbilt-2.5 vs Missouri

Super Dog Picks:
Kirk Herbstreit: Northwestern+7.5 vs Nebraska
Desmond Howard: Mississippi State+7.5 vs Texas
Stanford Steve: Ole Miss+5.5 vs Oklahoma
Pat McAfee: ???????
Nick Saban: NC State+6.5 vs Pittsburgh
Rece Davis: Minnesota+8.5 vs Iowa

They picked Indiana/UCLA against the spread:
Kirk/Desmond: UCLA+27.5 vs Indiana
Pat/Nick/Nate: Indiana-27.5 vs UCLA

Celebrity guest Nate Bargatze:

North Dakota State over South Dakota State
LSU over Texas A&M
Texas over Mississippi State
Vanderbilt over Missouri
BYU over Iowa State
Minnesota over Iowa
Ole Miss over Oklahoma
Memphis over South Florida

Kirk Herbstreit:

North Dakota State over South Dakota State
Texas over Mississippi State
Vanderbilt over Missouri
BYU over Iowa State
Iowa over Minnesota
Oklahoma over Ole Miss
South Florida over Memphis

Desmond Howard:

North Dakota State over South Dakota State
Texas A&M over LSU
Mississippi State over Texas
Missouri over Vanderbilt
BYU over Iowa State
Iowa over Minnesota
Ole Miss over Oklahoma
South Florida over Memphis

Pat McAfee:

South Dakota State over North Dakota State
Texas A&M over LSU
Mississippi State over Texas
Vanderbilt over Missouri
BYU over Iowa State
Iowa over Minnesota
Oklahoma over Ole Miss
South Florida over Memphis

Nick Saban:

North Dakota State over South Dakota State
Texas A&M over LSU
Texas over Mississippi State
Vanderbilt over Missouri
BYU over Iowa State
Iowa over Minnesota
Oklahoma over Ole Miss
South Florida over Memphis